looking for credible options

Scotland’s future energy needs

Published:

THE SNP and Labour appeared united for once yesterday, but only in the sense that they both thought they had the right answer for Scotland’s future energy needs.

Not surprisingly, they were at opposite ends of the spectrum as to the means of achieving this daunting task. The SNP has slammed the door on nuclear power north of the border while Labour in London has finally embraced it as the only credible option despite its obvious drawbacks and dangers.

The Scottish Government, meanwhile, has planted its flag firmly in the green, renewable energy camp.

Scotland gives the appearance of being well placed to make the most from this, given the wealth of sea and wind power at its disposal. A boom in jobs and enough energy to fulfil the country’s needs have been the subject of bold predictions.

The first minister went as far as saying that nuclear power had been proven to be unnecessary. Others would argue that nuclear power is proven to deliver, despite the unpleasant baggage it carries with it, while no one knows for sure whether or not green energy will match the predictions.

While our political leaders might feel confident predicting the future, not many saw the energy crisis coming with its spiralling prices and doubts about the security of future gas supplies from eastern Europe.

There is an old saying about not putting all your eggs in one basket for fear of losing the lot. Very little about energy policy appears to be joined up at the moment.

A mix of energy options which taps into various sources would seem sensible to protect the country’s future needs. It’s sensible, but not politically-correct.