Youth council criticised over BNP article

By Cameron Brooks

Published: 10/07/2009

A group of aspiring politicians have come under fire for using taxpayers’ money to promote the British National Party, it emerged last night.

Aberdeen City Youth Council, which receives £5,000 a year from the local authority to cover operating costs, has been criticised for giving over a full page in its monthly newsletter to Scottish BNP leader Gary Raikes.

In the article, Mr Raikes, who lives at Turriff, argues that the BNP, having won two seats at the European Parliament elections last month, is a legitimate political party.

He said the commonly-held belief that the party – which does not have a single seat in Scotland – consisted of “racist hate-mongers” was outrageous.

Mr Raikes’s assertion comes after BNP leader Nick Griffin, recently elected an MEP, came under fire for saying the EU should sink boats carrying illegal immigrants to prevent them entering Europe.

Paul Robertson, 18, chairman of the youth council, which has 30 members aged 14-25, defended the article.

He said the organisation was “apolitical” and opinion pieces published in the widely distributed newsletter were “very successful in inspiring debate”.

But John Stewart, Aberdeen City Council’s leader-in-waiting, said yesterday he was “concerned and surprised” that the youth council, which gathers the views of young people across the city and beyond to help shape local authority policy, had decided to publish the article.

“I am surprised they have chosen to give publicity to a party like the BNP, whose views on a number of issues are not particularly savoury,” he said. “I am disappointed to hear there is no challenge to the points made in the article. It is not helpful to give any political party unfettered space.”

Labour group secretary Willie Young said: “It is understandable young people will be inquisitive about political parties but the youth council has gone too far by providing the BNP with free publicity at the taxpayers’ expense.”

Conservative group secretary Alan Donnelly said: “I am all for trying to get people involved in politics but I do not think promoting an extreme right-wing party is a good use of public money.”

Mr Robertson, an economics and politics student at Aberdeen University, said: “Aberdeen City Youth Council is an apolitical organisation.

“The short opinion piece, therefore, contains a disclaimer, which reiterates our apolitical status and states that opinions expressed in articles that are submitted to us do not represent the views of our organisation.”

Deputy council leader Kevin Stewart said the youth council published an article castigating the BNP recently and the latest newsletter piece was a right to reply.

Reader's Comments

What utter hypocrisy from Cllr Willie Young. It was his party which spent the entire Euro election campaign talking up the BNP and doubtless gained them many extra votes, in a pathetic attempt to scare folk into voting Labour. Then, to cap it all off, they implemented a policy in England on housing which was basically a BNP policy. Perhaps Cllr Young may wish to check his own house is in order before he attacks the young people of Aberdeen
Jane Spencer
Report this comment

blah,blah,blah,blah,Jane Spencer,spouting rubbish as usual.
Stan Domeracki
Report this comment

blah, blah, blah, blah, Stan Domeracki, giving all his love to Labour as usual
Jane Spencer
Report this comment

Jane cant you come up with something more original, plagerism is for those who have no thoughts of their own.Labour no I dont think so, try again.
Stan Domeracki
Report this comment

There is no point in electing a Youth Council if we are going to restrict what they say. If they feel this guy deserves a full page spread then that is what THEY feel, we have no right to give them grief for doing it. Besides, if the BNP are talking tripe, then the more we hear from them the less support they will get. Scotland is heading for Independence and the last thing Scots want to hear is the irrelevance of the BNP to that aim. But the Youth Council must be free to experiment and that includes making as many mistakes as it can, what better way to learn. Go for it guys. Oh, and don't forget Scottish Oil revenues and the Independence arguments too for future discussion.
Brian Hill
Report this comment

Two points - what makes Cllr Donnelly think the bnp are an extreme right wing party ? Any objective look at their policies on nationalisation industry economics etc would show they are very much aligned to the hard left, secondly who "elected" this youth parliament ? How many people voted for their "representatives" ?
A.N. Other
Report this comment

I think the young people come out of this better than those who are complaining about them. Google for Aberdeen City Youth and the council page tells you what they are about and gives newsletters - only up until April though.
John Duncan
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.