Councillor to stay despite vendetta

Published: 20/08/2009

A councillor subjected to sustained verbal attacks over a planned Highland incinerator plant insisted yesterday she would continue to serve her community, despite the vendetta that led her to boycott the meeting that sank the project.

In her first interview about the two-month ordeal, tearful Cromarty Firth Independent councillor Carolyn Wilson described yesterday how she was the victim of a misconception that she was in favour of the proposal for Invergordon.

She told the Press and Journal the confusion stemmed from a council document she and others had signed, requesting a separate planning application – for a waste transfer station – be reconsidered.

Mrs Wilson, a 52-year-old mother-of-three who owns the Victoriana florist in Alness High Street, said anxious residents following the debate at public meetings linked the two issues and assumed that she backed the incinerator plan.

She was unable to speak publicly about it before a council debate.

“Because, at a public meeting, the community council advised people to write to me to make their feelings known, I became the focus of all the objections, letters and e-mails,” Mrs Wilson said. “They made it clear I had something to do with it.

“I had people come into my shop and intimidate me.

“One person suggested if I didn’t make the ‘right decision’ I would be subjected to further action. Others snubbed me.

“All this came from people I have worked with, live near and people I have respected. The advice from the council’s legal department was to say nothing.

“I did not think the health risks of an incinerator talked about were insignificant.

My husband, Warwick, has suffered for 20 years from an illness caused by organophosphate poisoning, so I’m somebody who takes it very seriously.

“It’s been difficult. I’ve never backed off from making my views known, especially on a local issue.

“I’d never felt frightened about going to a meeting. The worst part was my family feeling threatened and, when it affected my kids – my two daughters work at the shop – that was the worst bit.”

Asked how she would have voted at Tuesday’s area planning meeting in Invergordon, Mrs Wilson said: “I didn’t hear everything that was said, so I couldn’t tell you.”

Reader's Comments

May I remind readers that the anti incinerator brigade represented a minority of the people in Cllr Wilson's ward. They certainly did not have a majority of voters behind them, as apparently several hundred of the petitioners were under age. On more than one occasion, when I spoke to members of the Invergordon Community Council I was assured 'we' lived in a democratic society and everyone was entitled to his or her opinion. The abuse that has been, and still is being, bandied about anyone who opposed the protester's stance, whether a member of the public or Highland Council, makes a mockery of that statement. Protesters Ms Karen Mackay, Catherine Richardson, Tina McCaffery and Liz Wilson, have published, what may well prove to be defamatory remarks, on the internet about me personally. Lets wait and see.
Euilleam Ross
Report this comment

Mr Ross, I have never made any defamatory remarks about you on the internet or anywhere else, as you would have done too, I have kept all the correspondence which I have been involved with, so I think that this is very unfair. I think that what carolyn has described has been terrible and I have spoken with her about this - from our conversation I sent out an e-mail to everyone I knew involved with the campaign saying how I was really upset that someone would receive any horrible e-mails or letters and how I totally did not support this. I would never support or encourage this type of behaviour and I am really upset about your comment regarding me.
karen mackay
Report this comment

Dear Mr Ross I read your claims with interest. Now is a wonderful opportunity for you to present your evidence regarding your claims. I have seen the evidence gathered by the campaigners. I'm not referring to the petition but a door to door survey of households in Saltburn and Woodside gardens The number of respondents was 82 households of which 3 households in favour of the incinerator and 79 against. Please supply your data for the whole of ward 07 Cromarty Firth as we are all ears or should I say eyes. I'm sure Mrs Mackay would not be against you reprinting her defamatory remarks here while you are at it.
muzz mackay
Report this comment

As per usual Mr Ross does not have his facts correct. As mentioned before he never attended any meetings in the town whereby he would have been able to educate himself on the true facts of the very successful campaign. Assumptions and stories are not truths. At what age are you not a member of the community? I look forward to seeing these alleged "defamatory remarks" that I am supposed to have posted on the internet - Bring it on! The name is Richmond not Richardson!
Catherine Richmond
Report this comment

Dear Mr Ross, In response to your comments again today, at no point yesterday was I abusive nor was I deflammatory to you, I purely stated the truth you have not been to any meetings nor did you attend the hearing that named you as a supporter, due to you not having the facts you are unfortunatley misguided and misinformed, your comments today clearly show this. There were 2 petitions one from the adults which had 2,000 signatures and every one of those signatures counts and the other one was from the youths which contained 170 signatures and yes I can assure you that their voice does count they are the future and they are entitled to be heard on an issue that affects them and their future. With regards the campaigners being in the minority again Mr Ross please provide your evidence of this as we have done in the public domain, even more evidence that we are the majority not the minority is the Big Vote that was conducted by The Ross-shire that stood at 87% against on the day of the hearing and is in the public domain. With regards Carolyn Wilson I do not believe that any member of this campaign group has threatened nor verbally abused her and if she has indeed recieved anything like this I would strongly recommended that she goes to the police and brings it in to the public domain so that those people can be punished. Again Mr Ross I reiterate please feel free to ask for a meeting where you can put yourside and listen to ours or if you prefer as I stated yesterday I will happily hire a van and bring all the evidence round for you to go through at your leisure over the next few weeks as there is so much of it. I trust that this has cleared up any misunderstanding that you may have had with regards my comments.
Tina McCaffery
Report this comment

Silence from Mr Ross, but all is not lost. His silence is very telling of both his character and integrity. I can safely regard both with the derision they deserve.
muzz mackay
Report this comment

Oh I spoke too soon we have had a reply of sorts in the shape of a strange 'news' letter. Unfortunately there's still no evidence for his claims that the anti incinerator 'brigade' are in the minority. An amusing part of this rant is the reprinting of the so called defamatory comments which clearly are not. The best is saved for last when Ross describes the above rebuttals of his nonsense as apologies. Everyone had a good laugh about it as nobody can take this man seriously anymore. So you still strike out on the credibility factor but you do get delusional added to your character.
muzz mackay
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.