Calman changes poised to give HOLYROOD power on gun law

Air-weapon victims hail hope of ban in Scotland

By Stephen Christie

Published: 23/11/2009

Politicians and victims of air-gun crime last night welcomed proposals that would give Holyrood the power to ban the weapons in Scotland.

Firearms legislation is now reserved to Westminster but, in his review on devolution, Sir Kenneth Calman recommended its transfer to the government north of the border.

Scottish Secretary Jim Murphy is preparing to deliver his response to the Calman report, which made a series of recommendations on which powers Scotland should have.

Air-gun crime has become more prevalent in recent years and the Scottish Government has argued for more control, saying Scotland has a distinct problem with air weapons that needs to be tackled.

A spokesman for Michael Russell, Scottish minister for culture, external affairs and the constitution, said: “These changes should be happening right now.

“Bringing responsibility for firearms legislation to Holyrood will allow us to create a firearms regime that meets Scotland’s needs, concerns and circumstances.”

Last night, a young woman who was almost blinded when she was shot in the face with an air-rifle pellet said she welcomed anything that could lead to the banning of the weapons in Scotland.

Claire Ewen, 23, of Printfield Walk, Aberdeen, was walking in the city in April when she was targeted. The pellet is still lodged in her cheek because doctors were concerned about the complexity of the operation to remove it.

She said: “Air guns in the wrong hands can be very dangerous and I think it’s right that the Scottish Government should have the power to ban them.”

Catherine McKinnon, of Califer Road, Forres, Moray, had to send her cat to live with a friend, Julie Munro, after it was targeted by someone with an air rifle.

Jack, just 14 months old, had to have its left foreleg amputated after being hit by a pellet near Ms McKinnon’s home in October.

“They should not be available,” said Ms McKinnon, 48. “If they weren’t, then they would not get into the wrong hands.”

Mrs Munro, 58, said: said: “It’s an absolute farce when you think different types of guns have checks and yet, with an air gun, anyone can walk in and buy one over the counter.”

Earlier this year, villagers reacted with anger when a woman in her 40s was shot with an air-gun pellet on a road at Ardcroy, Croy.

On October 10, Tayside Police were called to New Wynd, Montrose, following reports of a woman being injured on her face in an alleged air-gun attack.

It came less than 24 hours after a 15-year-old girl was allegedly shot in the eye with a BB gun in Baluniefield Road, Dundee.

In 2005, Andrew Morton, 2, was shot and killed by an air-gun pellet in Glasgow.

Aberdeen councillor Norman Collie, who has fought for more than three years to ban the weapons in the city, said it was only a matter time before more deaths were caused by the weapons.

He said last night: “The whole of Scotland is suffering as a result of the dangers posed by these weapons. They are not toys and people need to realise how deadly they can be.”

Mr Collie added: “The problem I have always faced in my campaign is that there has been too much complication in legislation with Westminster holding the cards.”

Labour MSP Jackie Baillie said the devolution of power would be welcomed across political parties.

“This is very good news indeed, because it is something that the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government has been calling for,” she said.

In March 2008, the UK Government rejected a call from SNP ministers for a review of gun laws.

A Scotland Office spokesman said the UK Government would be setting out its response to Calman “very shortly” and that “air weapons will be dealt with”.

Reader's Comments

The banning of firearms in the UK after Dunblane did nothing to halt the use of them, in fact the opposite is true. The legitimate sports shooter was denied access to the tools of his sport, the banning of airguns will have no effect on their availability of those so inclined to have one. A licence to own one might be a step in the right direction.
William Hindley
Report this comment

William you are 100% correct. Any one pointing a weapon at another person with the intention to wound or kill is not going to worry if it is legal to have or not.In fact the mentality of these people is that it is "cool" to be in possession of such an item. It is the lack of proper punishment for those using the weapons inappropriately when they get caught.
Keith Stirton
Report this comment

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/north_east/8374330.stm
manniewe naename
Report this comment

Firstly I must state any misuse of an airgun should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law and I have no sympathy for those who commit violent crime BUT The previous posters have it right, there are very effective laws in place for the prosecution of anyone misusing air guns the VCR bill has it all in black and white but rather than enforce the law the politicians are baying to ban air guns and the public seem happy to abdicate personal responsibility and prefer to leave it to the state to add yet another ban. I am chairman of an air rifle club which has 30+ shooters from ages 12 to 70, it is a family sport enjoyed by all who attend, we have a strict code of conduct and ensure all members pass the message along to non members, we compete every month like many clubs all over Scotland. The thing is air gun users are a small disjointed group, we don't have the finances to launch a big lobbies so make an easy target for politicians to bandstanding against and grab headlines. It's interesting how often they use the word "alleged", "alleged" means not proven, or if you are an airgunner it seems "guilty before proof"! Maybe some facts would help, since banning hand guns, hand gun crime is worse than ever, more people and "Killed or seriously injured" on horses, bikes, cars and DIY than with air guns yet no calls to ban those activities. Oh and a "BB gun" is NOT an airgun! though even those are now controlled as "Softair". In Scotland we have a governing body for target shooters in SARPA, most people who do vermin control are insured by BASC, SACS or BASA all responsable users, these are the people who will be punished for the crimes of unruly kids who's parents have not seen fit to give them the education they need before letting them loose "On the streets". Most airgun users have no issue with a licence scheme but see it as unworkable and an issue that needs to remain under the governance of Westminster so any solution put in place would be workable. Sorry this has been a bit wordy but we are tired of being branded as irresponsible gun nuts for the actions of the undisciplined, unlawful few. Maybe the likes of Norman Collie should come talk the likes of our shooting clubs before trying to ban them!
Graham Ellis
Report this comment

Some more facts. Dr Colin Shedden, Director of BASC Scotland said: "Scottish government figures show that airgun offences have halved over the last 12 years – down from 1 150 in 1995-6 to 567 in 2007-08. Politics aside, the practical difficulties of devolving control over airguns have been repeatedly highlighted by BASC and the dramatic reduction of offences and incidents involving airguns asks the question whether such radical change is actually required
Graham Ellis
Report this comment

Air Rifle shooting in its various disciplines is enjoyed by many sports men and sports women young and old in and around Aberdeen and in the country as a whole. And the vast majority are responsible air gun users. Air rifles are also a vital tool for preventing the spread of disease by pest control of for example rats feral pigeon and the grey squirrel. Unfortunately however it is the responsible air gunning community who will be victimized and threatened with loss of its sports equipment due to these mindless criminals it is indeed a sorry state of affairs. All that will happen is that the law abiding individual will be penalized while the criminal will most probably revert to the next available item such as crossbows, catapults and baseball bats along with the kitchen knife he or she already has in their armory. Not to dismiss the issues that these criminals are bringing to the forefront of the media attention but a visit to the local A&E on a Saturday night will show how many knife and bottle victims we have but it would be preposterous to suggest a ban on beer bottles and Stanley knifes as the law abiding public would be uproar if this where to happen. It’s not the air rifle that is causing the issue whether it be a cheaply made rifle or and expensive £1200 rifle it’s the fool who is pulling the trigger that is causing so much harm and distress. Education of these people is what is required. Organization’s such as the Grampian Air Rifle Club prioritize and coach safe gun handling to air rifle owners in the area. Though I doubt that the mindless individuals responsible for these deplorable acts are the kind of person who would put themselves forward for this type of activity.
Jason Topley
Report this comment

This proposed ban is only going to affect the law abiding club and pest control users of air guns. The law surrounding use of air guns is already more than robust in the UK and it's only the Police / Court system not enforcing those laws that allow those that break the law to get away with a slap on the wrists. Banning air guns will only penalise the legal and law abiding citizens of the country. There are tens of thousands of airgun users in the UK that shoot responsibly and nothing is mentioned of the good work they do in promoting safe and responsible handing of air guns at the many clubs around Scotland and the UK. It's the mindless minority yet again dictating what way the laws will go instead of sorting the problem out at source and allowing the law abiding people to carry on and enjoy their sport / work in peace.
Ian Will
Report this comment

This is all wrong, banning airguns will not stop the mindless minority of criminals breaking the law. The Airgun is not to blame for violent crime,it is the person who pulls the trigger. Stuart Webb
stuart webb
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.