Highest-paid civil servants could lose 5% of their pay

SNP targets top earners to cut state wage bill

By Stephen Christie

Published: 14/12/2009

The Scottish Government is considering cutting the pay of high-earning public-sector workers by 5%.

The move would affect people on the highest income, including those working for the health service, councils, universities and government agencies.

Research indicates that about £600million is spent across government paying a small number of top officials salaries that are greater than those paid to government ministers.

It is understood that a 5% cut from the biggest earners would free up about £30million in public money, which could be redistributed to lower-paid staff.

SNP Finance Secretary John Swinney accepted last night that the highest paid must shoulder the biggest burden.

He said: “What the government has of course done already is that we’ve frozen our own pay as ministers. We’ve set an example. We’ve made clear that for senior civil servants there will be a pay freeze into the bargain.

“We’ve made it clear that we intend to extend that pay freeze amongst high earners within the public sector and we will continue to look at other ways of developing what’s going to be a very significant pressure on the pay bill within the public sector over the years to come.

“It is the highest paid who must shoulder the biggest burden.”

The 5% pay cut for high earners is a key demand of the Liberal Democrats in the negotiations that will determine if the minority SNP government can get its budget through Holyrood next year.

Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Tavish Scott said: “We’re asking the government to look at the overall public-sector pay bill in Scotland and take out 5% across that pay bill at the very top – in other words, on people earning more than £100,000 – so that we can protect people at the bottom and also help with the overall pressure the finances of the public sector are under.”

He said 1,200 people in the NHS earned over £100,000. The bill was £300million, £50million of it as bonuses.

“We want to make sure some of that money is used to help people at the bottom – the cleaners, nurses, the auxiliary staff – as well as helping with the overall state of the public finances,” he said.

About 150 employees in NHS Highland alone fall into the £100,000 pay bracket, while in higher education Dundee University has about 50 staff in that category.

When asked whether the pay cut was a bottom-line issue for the Lib Dems, Mr Scott said: “We certainly hope that they will accept this particular argument, yes.”

Scottish Labour finance spokesman Andy Kerr raised doubts about the Lib Dem proposal, however.

He said: “We certainly also called for a pay freeze on the highest earners, but I’m not sure that’s the top of my list of priorities in relation to how we actually stimulate economic growth and get Scotland back to work.”

Reader's Comments

Of course to show a good example and to take their share of the burden all our wonderful M.S.P.'s will also take a 5% cut in salary. Doubtless they will also cut expenses by a similar amount and all will then be well in our World.
David Sutherland
Report this comment

It's the Liberal Democrats who called for this, and the SNP are considering it.
Neil Fletcher
Report this comment

lower paid staff if you believe that you will believe anything, please do not believe this rubbish dont vote for anyone everyone stop voting
bob seivwright
Report this comment

Well it seems that the SNP can "Maybe" do something right if they agree to this proposal. Pity it takss blackmail to do it though. They will consider it if the Lib Dems agree to the SNP budget going through. Is this really how we want out government to run. SNP has spent more money and resources on their idealistic "Independance" than real problems like Education, Police Health etc. OH yes they way they have cut proscription prices that is good, but still window dressing. Free parking at hospitals again good again window dressing. Now the health boards have no money to improve parking. Great. will this government give them the money. OH Yes they say, but none is forthcoming. As usual with this SNP government all talk and very little action.
minnie moan a lot
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.