Traffic boss condemns road gridlock as ‘shambolic’

By Keith Findlay

Published: 18/12/2009

Roads in and around Aberdeen will grind to a halt unless action is taken to stop the snarl-ups getting worse, north-east transport supremo Sir Moir Lockhead has warned.

According to Sir Moir, chief executive at Granite-City-based bus and rail company FirstGroup, the frustrating tailbacks are the worst ever.

He said the situation had deteriorated since the Union Square shopping centre opened at the end of October, leaving FirstGroup’s buses stuck in the jams.

With many of the bus services running late, fewer people wanted to use them, according to Sir Moir, who wants a thorough review of traffic patterns. He said FirstGroup, the council and Aberdeen University were in talks about a study of traffic flow patterns, with a view to finding solutions.

“The situation we have just now is shambolic,” he said, adding: “Our buses have never been affected more and we are now having to compensate for delays by changing services. The number of late buses has grown dramatically.”

Sir Moir said lessons had not been learned from when the Bon Accord shopping centre opened in 1990, resulting in problems.

Other developments, such as a major revamp of Union Terrace Gardens, were being considered with little or no thought for the traffic implications, he added.

Public transport users now had “wonderful” new facilities at the bus and train stations but the congestion was making life a misery for thousands of people coming in and out of the city centre, said Sir Moir. He added. “It just can’t go on like this. The city will grind to a complete halt.

Sir Moir said there seemed to be no consistency in traffic flow measures.

He highlighted the infamous Haudagain roundabout – one of Aberdeen’s worst bottlenecks – having no traffic lights.

The FirstGroup boss admitted the company’s bus operations had been affected by a three-week strike by drivers earlier this year, but efforts to get people to use the services were now being hampered due to clogged roads.

Aberdeen City Council enterprise, planning and infrastructure director, Gordon McIntosh, insisted the problems were not as bad as Sir Moir made out.

Mr McIntosh added: “Work from a range of partners on traffic management during the lead-up to the opening has so far reaped benefits.

“Despite the traffic, the roads have operated well without the gridlock that was predicted.”

Reader's Comments

Well Mr McIntosh must have his head planted firmly up his own ar*e! Obviously he hasn't tried heading south along Market Street using the outside lane only to find that it's backed up with people trying to turn right into the car park for the shopping center?
Colin Hossack
Report this comment

Ha! Ha! this endorses what I have been saying for years.. there IS no real infrastructure plan, Bus lanes which have taken over what was once a lane for everyones use, and there is now more cars using less road, nae exactly rocket science that there is going to be problems. And there is a department with people that get paid to make this mess????????Bus lanes that can be used at certain times others that can't be used at all. Islands placed in the middle of the roads at bus stops so no one can pass a stopped bus. Bendy busses that should be banned from use in Aberdeen as they are far too big and cause grid lock at round-a-bouts and other junctions.Painting direction signs on the roads is of no assistance if they are covered up with queing traffic. Yes MR Lockhead you are correct it is a SHAMBLES but no one will listen....
Keith Stirton
Report this comment

I have maintained this for years.. There IS NO infrastructure plan in the City. Roads that used to be for everyones use taken over by busses. Bendy busses that are too big for the city that cause grid lock at round-a-bouts and other junctions. Traffic islands in the centre of the road at bus stops so you can not pass a stopped bus?? who thought that one up? Some bus lanes you can use at off peak times others you can't use at all.. Yes Mr Lock head you are correct Bus lanes in Aberdeen are a SHAMBLES.. Come on Aberdeen Give us our roads back.. There is no real problem with the Haudagain roundabout it is the idiots that use it and wont stay in the correct lane...
Keith Stirton
Report this comment

Oh me, there appears to be an echo in here :-)
Keith Stirton
Report this comment

Maybe getting the Aberdeen By-Pass up and running would reduce some of the 1000's of vehicle that use the City roads. Then get the roads working so that those that have to use them can do so in a better way. The roads are a shambles. Bus lanes, One way streets, so called "traffic calming measures". Maybe the so called department concerned with planning and infrastructure should try driving round the problem areas, oh i meant the WHOLE of the city, and lets see how much fun they find it, and how frustrating it is for the folk who do it everyday. Just think if the roads actually got people to places without the "gridlock feel" there wouldn't be some much anger and hassle on the roads. Get the money spent where it needs to be spent .......... not on just another building for the council!!!!
Caralynn Green
Report this comment

The bypass will have minimal impact on the traffic problems in Aberdeen. The official figures from the AWPR confirm this.
David Cutteridge
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.