Another SNP call for power line to go underground

By iain ramage

Published: 12/01/2010

Another SNP politician is urging power firm Scottish and Southern Energy to act on objectors’ calls for burying sections of the proposed replacement Beauly-Denny transmission line to preserve the scenery.

There appears little likelihood that it will, however, judging by a letter from a company official who stated in yesterday’s Press and Journal, that the transmission line “does not pass through any of Scotland’s designated National Scenic Areas”.

Last week Ochil MSP Keith Brown pressed the power giant to respond to public demands for substantial mitigation measures to avoid visual blight posed by 600 pylons, each 214ft high.

Yesterday, Highlands and Islands MSP Dave Thompson questioned Energy and Tourist Minister Jim Mather on the issue of burying sections of the new, 137-mile long power line.

He welcomed his colleague’s approval of the project, saying it would “help kick-start Scotland's renewable energy industry”. But he has revealed he will meet SSE officials “to continue to apply pressure for key sections of the line to be placed underground to limit their impact on the surrounding environment”.

Mr Mather said it would be “technically unfeasible to underground anything like the whole line”, and warned that burying cables on some stretches “could cause greater (environmental) damage.”

Mr Mather has admitted he does not have any powers to order the developer to bury the line.

He has asked SSE to “mitigate” the impact in some key areas, including the Cairngorms National Park and near the Balblair substation, at Beauly.

The letter from SSE’s head of policy and public affairs, Keith MacLean, stated that “most of the new overhead line will be within a kilometre of an existing line of pylons, which will be dismantled”.

It added that the landscape, in key areas like the Cairngorms park, would be “improved through the removal of other power lines as part of the package”.

Reader's Comments

The WHOLE of Scotland is a National Scenic Area!
manniewe naename
Report this comment

Thought they wanted to encourage tourism. Well the tourists will have plenty pylons to view
minnie moan a lot
Report this comment

It should be pointed out that the pylons will replace, and follow the line of, existing pylons. However, they will be a bit bigger than the originals, and I think Dave Thompson's suggestion of burying the cables at particularly scenic areas is a reasonable one. No-one seems to have mentioned that many scenic parts of the Highlands have been ruined by great swathes of non-native trees planted by the Frestry Commission over the years.
Stuart West
Report this comment

When I was a wee boy, a great line of pylons marched across the centre of my father’s croft. For years we looked at them and wondered when we would get "the Hydro". As dusk fell, my father or I would go out to the "engine shed" and hand crank the Lister diesel, after checking the oil and filling the fuel tank on the wall. After Dad listened to the shipping forecast, he switched off the Master switch above his bed and I lay in bed watching the lights dim to darkness. Torches and candles, matches and paraffin lamps till daybreak. I was 13 when the overland cables reached the gable end and gave us instant heat, light and cooking...even television!!. Dark ages eh!! I'm only 52 now, the pylons still march over the old croft and I wouldn't change them for what went before! Some folk only see the pylons when they go out into the country! I hardly notice them now, or the increasing wind turbines that line the skyline in places. It is expensive to bury the cables, very expensive and difficult, not that it is easy to erect the pylons in many places, but what alternatives are really there?? A famous model was once asked how they felt about growing old...They replied it was the better option considering the alternatives! We should be asking ourselves what alternatives we are prepared to accept while we rant about pylons, windmills, hydro dams, Incinerators, nuclear power stations and the like! They have to go somewhere. Or would you like to be going out at 5 am, on some mornings like we have just had, to start a frozen Lister generator to boil a kettle for a hot cuppa!!
Donald Gillies
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.