Government rules out more funding to fix potholes

By Morag Lindsay

Published: 04/03/2010

THE Scottish Government has ruled out more funding for pothole repairs after residents in one north-east street claimed theirs was the worst road in the country.

A Holyrood spokesman said Finance Minister John Swinney had already found an extra £5million for councils to spend on roads repairs and councils would have to dig into their own budgets to fix the damage caused by the worst winter in decades.

Residents in Bressay Brae, Aberdeen, said their street had been left looking like the Grand Canyon with 119 potholes on a 100-yard stretch.

The city council was carrying out repairs yesterday.

Politicians said Bressay Brae was by no means an isolated case. Aberdeen MSP Brian Adam has received complaints about roads across the city.

“Some of the holes are not just dangerous to cars but could potentially cause accidents as people swerve to avoid them or are deflected after hitting one,” he said.

North-east MSP Richard Baker said roads throughout the region posed safety concerns for cyclists and motorists. “There could be a serious injury,” he added.

Like most local authorities, Aberdeenshire Council has recorded a sharp increase in reports of potholes caused by the harsh weather.

Infrastructure services committee chairman Peter Argyle said workers were battling to fix defects before they caused serious problems.

“Potholes are most common during the periods following severe frost-and-thaw cycles,” he said.

“Repairs are being carried out throughout the region and we would like to thank the public for their assistance on this matter.”

The average pothole costs £65 to mend and, before this winter, campaigners said drivers in Scotland could encounter one every 120 yards.

The AA has predicted there will be three times as many holes on the roads of Britain by the time spring arrives.

A spokesman said yesterday that the motoring organisation’s insurance division was receiving three times as many claims for damaged wheels from drivers as usual.

Paul Watters, head of roads policy at the AA, said the figures were probably the tip of the iceberg, since most people do not bother claiming.

“Councils are already putting extra money into road repairs, but I would imagine they are going to have to go to the governments north and south of the border and ask for more,” he said.

A Scottish Government spokesman said it had already announced an additional £5million to be shared between the 32 local authorities to fix roads.

“On potholes we have made available an extra £5million for councils that comes on top of the almost £12billion in funding for local authorities next year.

“The settlement also matches our commitment to ensure local government continues to receive an increasing share of the Scottish budget to enable councils to meet priorities such as maintaining roads.”

If the extra £5million was divided equally between the 32 local authorities each council would receive £156,250 – enough to repair 2,400 potholes at £65 per hole.

Reader's Comments

So what are they doing with all the road tax money they take in over a year? This could pay for the up keep of all Britain’s roads including pot holes. That’s why we have to pay road tax to keep our roads up to a decent standard, instead the Government siphon off most of it and just leave the local councils to foot the bill.
Robert Horne
Report this comment

And yet there was enough money to close Pitfodels Station Road for a few days this past week while they built speed bumps. The tarmac used and labour expended would have repaired a number of roads. I am about to change my car and will now consider a 4x4. After all they are developed from farmer's vehicles and are suitable for the city's farm tracks. Also they all passed me when I was stuck on un-gritted roads.
David Hutchinson
Report this comment

Presumably they'll then be happy to pay compensation to the owners of cars with suspension damage due to these potholes. They always find money for unimportant things like foreign aid but never for things that affect the taxpaying public
William Hindley
Report this comment

Presumably they'll then be happy to pay compensation to the owners of cars with suspension damage due to these potholes. They always find money for unimportant things like foreign aid but never for things that affect the taxpaying public
William Hindley
Report this comment

Make sure to sue the council if their negligence damages your property. If there is a big pot hole you're concerned about take a photograph of it with a rule illustrating its depth. Send it to the council - if you don't know the department just send it to the Chief Executive, he/she will know. Advise them of the exact location of the hazard and your intention to recover your costs in the event of damage. This will prevent the council denying negligence on the grounds that they were not aware of the pot hole.
Ubi D
Report this comment

You oughtto try navigating Salisbury Terrace, potholes everywhere and particularly vicious craters at the very badly constructed sleeping policemen.
Richard Dewar
Report this comment

You oughtto try navigating Salisbury Terrace, potholes everywhere and particularly vicious craters at the very badly constructed sleeping policemen.
Richard Dewar
Report this comment

No disrespect intended to anybody who lives in Summerhill, but, if this was say, somewhere in the Queens Road area, you can be sure that the money would have been found.
Ian Stewart
Report this comment

Try driving between the Kingswells roundabout and Cults it is simply beyond belief especially the junction at the top of Countiswells Road, but hey the council know about it and have taken measures. Yes they have put up "Uneven Road" signs, so that's ok then!
desperate red
Report this comment

i work in a local garage repair centre,and let me tell you that that the average repair for a broken suspension coil spring (front) is between £150- £195 depending on model of car -the amount we replace due to potholes is around a dozen a week. -if all these were claimed back by vehicle owners,then £65.00 a pothole to repair is not bad,eh? if your car has been damaged,get a photograph of the pothole and of the broken/damaged component and ask for two copies of our invoice-one to you one to send off with your claim and log on to directgov website and search :claiming against the council.sorry to rant,but many people cannot afford this extra expense due to ignorance of the council.i have just paid £215 for road tax and feel it will not go towards any road repairs.
daz windturbine
Report this comment

Considering how much motorist are taxed, through extortionate fuel duty, Road Tax and new showroom taxes, it is an absolute disgrace that the roads are as bad as they are. (the worst I have seen) I used to live near Bressay Brae and it has been plagued by dodgy road surfaces and "repairs" for years. These quick fixes are of no use as they quickly get torn up once again the following year. Its only a matter of time before someone gets caught out, loses control and loses their life.
Dasbo B
Report this comment

I have been driving in and around Aberdeen for 40 odd years now and definately the roads are in the worst state that I have ever witnessed. Basically we are now paying the price for 30 years of neglect and temporary patches becoming permanent. I reported to the council (Aberdeenshire) some potholes in the steet where I live, and sure enough the were attended to right away which rather impressed me. However it appears that all they did was drop cold tar into the holes and now two of them are as bad as ever and the rest are on the way to being as bad. These holes need sorting properly not just a bucket of cold tar tipped into them. Until they are properly repaired we are going to have ongoing problems and the job done again and again. Quite how it costs £65 to tip cold tar into a hole escapes me though.
Dave McGregor
Report this comment

You would think we lived in the south of France. The potholes will get worse when there is frost. What do they expect in the North East of Scotland. So why were they not prepared to get the roads sorted before the frost. Winter always comes as a surprise to our local councils. AS said above, this mismanagement has been going on for many years but has as usual been ignored. As for the Government turning down more money for Aberdeen. What else did the council expect.
minnie moan a lot
Report this comment

Why waste money on traffic calming measures? Just let nature do its best…….pot holes!!! Joking apart its become a disgrace that the Oil Capital of Europe's roads should become so shoddy.....
Fiona Cooper
Report this comment

http://www.potholes.co.uk/claims/how_to_claim
Keith Stirton
Report this comment

Road tax doesn’t exist. It was abolished in 1937, a process started 11 years earlier by Winston Churchill. We pay Vehicle Excise Duty, a tax on vehicles (the clue is in the name). VED is not a payment to use roads or a payment to fix or build roads. An annual payment gives you no right to use the road. VED cash all goes into central Government coffers. Pot hole fixing is paid for by local authorities via your poll tax. Read more about mythical 'road tax' at http://iPayRoadTax.com
Carlton Reid
Report this comment

It's funny that when the council or government issue press releases about speed bumps, lowering speed limits and speed cameras, etc... there's a lot of hand wringing about how much they care about road safety and saving lives or preventing injury. If the council *really* cared they would be vociferously campaigning for more money to fix the holes and accept nothing less. If the Scottish government cared, they'd free up funds. Or, why not get the crims on chain gangs fixing them instead of watching telly in a warm cell at our expense? BOTTOM LINE - THE AMOUNT OF POTHOLES ON THE ROAD SHOW HOW MUCH THE AUTHORITIES *REALLY* CARE ABOUT ROAD SAFETY. THEY DON'T...
Roger Savage
Report this comment

Drivers should slow down. Too many drivers speed: we need greater fines for speeding drivers.
don brad
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.