Any talk of immigration risks the dreaded R word

By NICOLA BARRY

Published: 05/05/2010

JUST when you think Gordon Brown cannot sink any lower in the opinion of the voters, he does exactly that, in spectacular fashion.

Every time he opens his big mouth, he forgets his microphone is still on.

However, bear in mind that his comment about Gillian Duffy could have been so much worse, especially if it has been made by a woman.

We really know how to bitch. Our prime minister, on the other hand, does not. Men call women bitches when they don’t get what they want from them. So, if a woman turns a man down for a date, she’s a bitch. If she races up the career ladder faster than he does, she’s a big, fat bitch and so on.

Women are far more likely to go for the jugular and drop some interesting bombshell about the target of their gossip.

Bitching is fine, provided you are with people you know and trust. In the case of the PM, the voters are not in that category.

As a result of all the fuss, Gillian Duffy is heading for mega stardom. She might even be the Susan Boyle of politics. An ordinary wee wifie, a widowed granny from Rochdale, suddenly thrust into the media spotlight from nowhere just like SuBo.

Suddenly, Gillian D has been revealed as a major player in the general election campaign, with the prime minister wanting to shake her hand for the TV cameras. Her name is now known nationally – possibly internationally. She is, if you like, notorious.

All because Gordon Brown, in a toe-curlingly embarrassing moment, dared to describe her as “a bigoted woman” after the poor soul raised the taboo subject of mass immigration.

Brown, who is also a poor soul these days, managed to forget for a moment that he is our servant and we are not his.

Mrs Duffy’s concerns are not difficult to comprehend. There are those who say she is not a racist; that she was just questioning Westminster’s immigration policy. Of course, there are thousands of Eastern Europeans here in Scotland and in the rest of the UK; people who have come here to find work. But Mrs Duffy’s choice of words was plain unfortunate. She talked about “flocking eastern Europeans” and it isn’t hard to see why Gordon Brown took this as a slur.

Many of these immigrants work far harder than Scots. They pay taxes. They have a right to our respect. However, whatever you think of what she said, you will probably admit that her sentiments are shared by a lot of other people who are too scared to say the words out loud. And, to question government policy on this matter is to leave yourself wide open to accusations of the R word.

No one can dispute the fact that parts of this country – and the north-east is no exception – have been all but swamped by incomers from abroad. Whether skilled white-collar workers or students seeking higher education, Eastern Europeans have been abandoning their homes in their thousands, in search of a mythical promised land. And to say so does not constitute racism.

Since joining the European Union in 2004, well over 1million Eastern Europeans have come to the UK, thought to be the largest single migration movement in history.

They have good reason to come here. Times are tough at home, with unemployment reaching an all-time high. Yes, membership of the EU has brought economic benefits but not fast enough for the country's disconsolate army of jobless.

True to their reputation, most immigrants from Eastern Europe work extremely hard and are prepared to do anything in order to earn a living. Their output is, by all accounts, prolific, their work ethic admirable. Those who have not been able to find jobs have been prepared to fill the most menial job vacancies around just to earn a crust. The jobs no one else seems to want. Others have converted derelict buildings into delicatessens or similar businesses.

Whatever anyone says in Mrs Duffy’s defence, to dismiss all these honest folk as a “flock”, implying they resemble sheep, following each other and baa baa-ing, is an insult to their integrity.

As political parties continue to debate the way forward for immigration, many politicians and would-be politicians cash in on our worst fears, on the insecurities of many white, working-class people who say they feel under siege.

But, in 2010, look around you and listen to your friends and neighbours and you will soon hear someone moaning about the invasion of foreigners. They do sound hostile, aggressive and, I’m afraid, racist.

Politicians tell us that unfettered immigration from the extended EU and beyond has stretched this country to breaking point, turning even the most liberal of citizens into something approaching rabid fascists. The popular argument is that people feel like strangers in their own country – an exaggeration, of course – but, it would take a twisted individual not to have some sympathy for their logic. Hence Mrs Duffy’s comments.

You can almost hear the BNP chortling with glee every time a court case comes up involving illegal immigrants and every time you see pictures of foreigners gathering at Calais, trying to reach the UK and its unquestioning benefits system.

I am beginning to sound racist, but, believe me, I’m not. This is what Labour has reduced us to.

Perhaps we are over-reacting to Gordon Brown’s gaffe. After all, if you lined up the number of people in this country who had muttered something about somebody else – the queue would stretch from here to China and back again.

Yet, even here, in Scotland, this simple, straightforward woman has touched us deeply. Could it be that Gillian Duffy, widow and lifelong socialist, is the psychological boost we all need to help us ride out the recession, at a time when we are all worried about our jobs and lifestyle? Or, is it simply the fact that an underdog has finally come up trumps and shown our scandal-ridden politicians where to get off?

Reader's Comments

With 9 job seeker after every vacancy in Scotland (STUC last week), with 45000 looking for council houses, there is no case for unlimited immigration so vote for a party willing to clamp down-UKIP
george Cormack
Report this comment

Another politically correct piece of fluff. Yes they may work hard but hey do take jobs from our own who may not work as hard, but then our benefit system stifles their need. They do apply pressure to our already overstretched resources, how much more tax are you willing to pay Nicola to enjoy this excessive immigration? In parts of the UK huge amounts of immigrants are unemployed costing us even more, it would be wonderful if everyone in the UK had work and paid taxes but in the real world that is not the case. This is not racist, its fact, immigration is out of control and only two parties seem to be brave enough to say it.
Dv Smith
Report this comment

I totally with the two guys above. The country is over run with immigrants, especially from Europe. I couldn't care less whether anybody thinks this comment is seen as racist or not. This is my opinion,, my country, and i have paid my taxes for more than 50 years. My family, over the generations have fought for this country. We now see it being swamped with immigrants, probably to please the European Union. Enough is enough. I do not include people from Commonwealth countries in this argument. I welcome them with open arms. We should give them priority to come here. They have given "their" blood for OUR country over the years. Many are related to people from this country. I have had enough of this European immigration experiment,,, it has,, and will forever cost us dearly,, unless we do something about it.
Tony Sherwood
Report this comment

Unfortuneately, the right of EU citizens to move throughtout member states is enshrined in law. What no one seems to mention is the large amount of UK citizens who live and work in other member states. By far the largest grouping moving to the UK are The Poles. They fought with us in the war and many settled and married here afterwards. While every nation has it's layabouts (we are no exception) the Poles still have a work ethic which we appear to have lost. Decades of lack of investment in training by companies and the UK government mean, regretably, we need immigrants to plug the holes in skills shortages. In the unskilled market, our crops would rot in the fields without Eastern European workers. But why are our significant numbers of youth unemployed not being directed into this type of work I wonder?
Ron Campbell
Report this comment

With a dire shortage of housing, no jobs to speak of, NHS overstretched it is difficult to make a case for the thousands upon thousands who flocked to our shores. Some indeed can speak English reasonably well but many do not so how on earth that is supposed to be of benefit, heaven only knows. As for the Eastern lot being harder workers - aye right. Give them a couple of months in a job and they are the biggest moaners of the lot.
Fi Donald
Report this comment

Spot on Fi!!!
Tony Sherwood
Report this comment

Sorry, I am usually quite reserved in these matters as a course of upholding a professional tone but I think the majority of the above are speaking absolute bol*ocks. I strongly believe that one of the single greatest things ever to happen to our country is the immigration of a diverse and complex range of cultures over the years. We now have a rich melting pot of arts, cuisine, culture, sport etc that is unparalleled because we have a free vote and a fantastic quality of life. Fi, the only reason we have a shortage of housing is because of the way social housing schemes have been handled in the past, with councils being more interested in selling city held land to housing developers who have built cheap appalling homes that are marketed exclusively at the middle class. This leaves council estates as sink holes in which only the poorest will ever move to as that is their only option. With regards to your comments about the NHS - it's free! What right do any of us have to complain. Your comment regarding moaning workers is just pathetic and trite so I shall ignore it. In response to Tony, by your logic because your family defended our shores in previous wars they hold some sort of high and mighty ground above immigrants? So does that mean you personally also hold some morale responsibility to the thousands dead in Dresden? Or maybe you forget that Britain has long been allies with certain countries in the past and that one of the reasons people want to move here is not because they are tax dodging, work shy plebs, but because they want a better quality of life and they are prepared to work in jobs that pay well in comparison to their home country and that most British people look down on.
Bill Simpson
Report this comment

I'm not denying that immigration is an issue, and when job and housing crisis hits, that is naturally the first thing people will point fingers at, and blame, and that is entirely understandable, and happens in every country. Howerver there are key pieces of information that are missing in the above comments. Foreigners that come to the UK to get a job, as legal immigrants, are not entitles to any benefits. Non whatsoever, so nobody is raping the system. That is why the Do get the jobs, rather than plebbing about and sponging off the system. They also pay full taxes on the jobs they have, just as the Uk national does. And the other form of legal immigrant is the student. Now the foreign student completing their course in the UK will pay just about as much if not more in tuition fees than the average UK tax payer in the span oh his working lifetime will contribute to the education and health sectors. That is a very cleverly calculated sum bu the universities, and in fact a lot of them rely on it, and that is the reason why when they struggle, they take in as high a percentage of foreign students as present in aberdeen. My point is that legal immigrants, along with the cultural and linguial contribution they bring to the country, do also bring in a significant economic value, and to be denied a chance at a life and job because of a call for a shift in policy is just daft. The problem on the other hand of illigaal immigration is quite a tangible one, but it is not being addressed at all, as all focus is being driven at limiting legal immigration, as this is far easier. So on the one side of the spectrum, foreign doctors, architects, and qualified individuals are literally having to piss blood to prove their worth just for a right at a job, while 9 out of 10 people selling the big issue are foregin, that make hardly any contribution, and can quite franlky have that same lifestyle anywhere.
Ved Mij
Report this comment

With two such extremes, what look like strict measures by the government to limit immigration, are in fact only affecting the legal migrants, that make a contribution anyway, and have no impact whatsoever on the more serious and wider problem, but it does however pull the wool over the public eye.
Ved Mij
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.