Letters Page

Published: 30/07/2010

SIR, – I welcome Alex Salmond’s efforts to end the throwaway culture in Scotland (the Press and Journal, July 29), but could he please pass a Scottish law that prevents Europe from forcing our Scottish fishermen to throw top-quality valuable fish back into the sea dead?

This plan would focus transforming waste into a valuable resource; it would generate valuable protein food to feed our nation with a value of over £100million a year.

This fish could be sold to Scottish processors and help to maintain and protect jobs with an opportunity to create further jobs.

Using waste as a resource would deliver great benefit to our fishing communities and help to promote a thriving fishing industry, with no downside to sustainable management.

I do not think you would find anyone in Scotland who would argue against such a law.

Andrew Charles,

19 Crombie Road,

Torry, Aberdeen.

SIR, – I read with dismay your story (July 26) stating that Grampian Chief Constable Colin McKerracher was to receive a £72,000 “performance-related” bonus.

That Aberdeen City Council, through the Grampian Joint Police Board, would make such a generous agreement in these difficult economic times is still further evidence that it lacks the ability to manage our city’s finances.

I find it impossible to believe that crime rates in Aberdeen are improving. We were told last September that the crime rate for assault was up 9% in Aberdeen city centre and Belmont Street was described as the worst beat in Scotland.

There is a problem with youths stealing motorcycles and taunting police about their crimes on social networking websites.

Certainly, statistics can be manipulated to present any picture desired. This is particularly true with crime statistics.

Some statistics are impossible to manipulate: road deaths continue to rise, 17 so far in 2010 compared with 14 last year. This must be attributable to the lack of a police presence on the roads.

Alan Craigie,

16 Auchmill Road,

Aberdeen.

SIR, – Your interesting report (July 29) on the transport of the forward fuselage section of Nimrod XV 254 to the Highland Aviation Museum, Inverness, was a little misleading.

Although it is good that the Inverness aircraft museum at Dalcross will have this forward section for display, it is not the only Nimrod to remain in Scotland as the report suggests.

A group of enthusiasts from RAF Kinloss and the local area have already acquired Nimrod XV 240, which is now on display as a complete airframe at the station’s Crash Gate 3, close to the Kinloss-Burghead public road.

This aircraft was first delivered to RAF Kinloss in July 1970 and converted to Mk2 status in 1983. It is a fitting and complete tribute to this fine maritime patrol aircraft that will remain on show at RAF Kinloss on a permanent basis.

David Morgan,

4 Beechway,

Forres.

SIR, – Having had first-hand experience of what happens when one requires medical treatment while on holiday in Spain, in my case Tenerife, I feel full holiday insurance should be purchased and the insurance company should be made aware of any medical condition you might have.

I sought medical help in Tenerife due to facial burns caused while wearing prescription sunglasses. My face and eyelids suffered quite horrific blistering and I required medical help.

I went along to the local hospital, which charged me 90 euros before I could see a doctor then, after assistance, another 200 euros. My holiday insurers paid my medical fees, less £50 excess.

I and the rest of my family have the European Health Insurance Card, but we are not sure what this entitles us to.

Gavin D. Elder,

150 Prunier Drive,

Peterhead.

SIR, – I would like to thank all the people at Spey Bay last Sunday afternoon who helped us to find our black labrador, Letty, which had gone into the River Spey and been swept away in the strong current.

We were joined at the riverside by two young girl cyclists and two young men in wetsuits.

I alerted members of the WDCS Wildlife Centre and several of the girls searched the pathways until eventually they found Letty, who had climbed out of the river farther downstream.

After some coaxing, a very wet but happy Letty was reunited with us and is none the worse for her ordeal.

Isobel and Jimmy Simpson,

5 Connage Cottages,

Rathven,

Buckie.

Reader's Comments

My letter before P&J cut the heart out of it. I read with dismay the article in Monday’s P&J stating that Grampian Chief Constable Colin McKerracher was to receive a £72,000 pound “performance” bonus. Firstly, that ACC would make such a generous agreement in these economic times is still further evidence that they lack any ability to properly manage our cities finances. Secondly, I find it impossible to believe that crime rates in Aberdeen are improving. We were told last Sept that the crime rate for assault was up 9% in Aberdeen centre with 8000 being reported. Belmont St was described as the worst beat in Scotland and we were all shown protracted assaults on CCTV with police not present. I’m also aware that there is a problem with youths stealing motorcycles and taunting police about their crimes on social networks. Certainly statistics can be manipulated to present any picture desired. This is particularly true with crime statistics where turning a blind eye to crime can remove statistical evidence. Just last week a young girl died of injuries in a local nightclub and the police ruled it ‘not suspicious’. Some statistics are impossible to manipulate: road deaths continue to rise 17 so far in 2010 compared to 14 last year. This must be attributable to the lack of a police presence on the roads. Even these tragedies aren’t included in Grampian police statistics as only road offences are listed. Stop policing the roads and the statistics show improvement. One wonders if the parents of Wesley Clark or Dayan Chibor feel Mr McKerracher deserves this bonus. I certainly don’t. I read with fascination Stuart Davidson’s (aka David Copperfield) account of the comparison of the differences in how policing was administered in Edmonton, Canada (Telegraph 24/7) where he now polices as compared to his former job in Manchester. By freeing officers from bureaucracy Edmonton’s police cost is 40% less than Manchester/capita. Given these inefficiencies combined with the incompetence exhibited in the Moat and Bird cases, UK police administrators should be receiving P45’s instead of bonuses.
Alan Craigie
Report this comment

Alan, I wholeheartedly agree with what you say. We would all like to see a greater police presence on our streets. The problem is, however, a morass of petty beaurocracy. It is my understaanding that, even in this day and age, officers have to complete five, separate, forms for each offence. Why? Surely, in this day and age of technology, much of this paperwork could be circumvented? Only when Mr McKerracher and his senior colleagues, along with The Fiscals, politicians and the legal profession at large get thier heads together to simplify proceedings, will matters improve. Earlier in the year I was involved in an incident in which three Scottish forces became involved. The lack of cohesion between them simply amased me. Perhaps one force, for the whole country, would improve matters. It would certainly reduce admin costs dramatically.
Ron Campbell
Report this comment

Alan, they probably edited it for length. But even without the P45 reference the printed version still makes a strong point.
Runcible the Fatuous
Report this comment

It's obscene that such a highly paid public servant, as Grampian Chief Constable, is to receive any bonus whatsoever. Is his grand salary for remunerating him for only doing a half-job; a 3/4 job; or 7/8th job??? If he is not fully commited & skilled to doing the best job possible, and achieving the best outcomes within his remit, then he shouldn't be there. Yes Alan, another instance of local government incompetence, firstly in having the "excessive" bonus in place, and secondly on the dubious measurement of performance, supposedly above and beyond the "call of duty"! Not sure about the 'Shire Councils, but ACC appear to stumble on from one faux pas to the next.
Alister Keir
Report this comment

seeing as (once again) there are no comments allowed on a positive UTG story, I thought I'd post it here. http://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/Article.aspx/1849606 - yes! the council have decided to put on "tartan day" in Union Terrace.... GARDENS! (read the story...oops, the PnJ omitted "Gardens" from "union Terrace"... doh! *ring ring* *ring ring* "Martin, It's Tom & Ian on the phone..." "oh no... they've heard about the celebration organised by the council in UTG"..."ach, we'll just cut 'gardens' from the story, no one will notice". Dear PnJ - come on, the game's up.
Philip Thompson
Report this comment

Alan Craigie,... I agree that crime is on the up but the recording of it will be on the decrease due to the poor response that the majority received in the past when they report an incident.Unless life threatening, most of us now have the attitude of "why bother".. I would like to know who worked out the bonus scheme, don't be surprised if the recipient didn't have a big hand in it him self.. in 2008 the BASIC salary was £126,471 this rose to £129,759 and is due to rise again in September this year to about £133,000... Please dont forget he also has a company Jag which is unlikely to be driven by himself and you can also bet that he will have various allowances similar to that of the Lord Provost.. There was a similar uproar at the end of last year with the Lothian & Borders Chief Constable.. "I do the job because I like to help people" is a thing of the past.. They only do the job because of the money, the time off with stress and full pay and the pension after early retirement....
Lord Lucan
Report this comment

Philip, the gardens have certainly had plenty of use this summer, and it's great to see all the activity they get.. the competition is meant to get launched in november isn't it.. once again, acsef time it well, in addition to giving it a bit of a break so that the outrage that the council's decision to keep pushing a flawed scheme on dies down, it also comes in just as the summer ends, and the bad weather starts, and gardens naturally get used less, so they can spint their whole 'now one goes to the gardens apart from druggies' story those that might consider entering the competition.. means whoever is looking at the gardens with the thought of entering the competition, gets to see it at it's lowest used time.. like any external public space, it has its good days and its bad days..
Ved M
Report this comment

Someone is doing their best to keep people away from UTG.. it has Michelle Mcmonument as the main guest... Yechhhhhh!!
Lord Lucan
Report this comment

"performance related bonus" + absence of police = reward for controlling and cutting costs from the police budget. Simple. The problem, therefore, is not with the administrator who carries out the reduction in police presence (and there must be a certain skill in implementing cuts whilst mitigating the inevitable rise in crime - get it badly wrong and it'd be pretty obvious). The problem is with whoever decided it would be a good idea to incentivise such administrative behaviour. Most likely a politician. Alan Cragie's points are good and well made, but I seem to remember him talking a very good game when it came to how the private sector's involvement with public affairs is a "good thing". For example, Wood's proposed investment of a fraction of the cost of the CS/GP project. However, implementing value-driven incentive schemes designed to increase shareholder returns clearly doesn't work for him when it comes to the local constabulary. That's interesting.
Richard Fraser
Report this comment

Yes Philip it does seem like they are deliberately omitting the word GARDENS from Union Terrace Gardens. Do you know what toilets all these people will be using?
Jaki Sinclair
Report this comment

I don't think I ever said the private sectors involvement in public affairs is a good thing Richard. I'm about small government, low taxes and maintaining our competitive position. Raised in Canada I find the big government Socialism here objectionable.
Alan Craigie
Report this comment

Of course UTG does not exist, nor does sanity. But concrete does, its lovely when wet and when it dries it entoum's many a pretty thing. and that is magic!
roger fontain
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.