Witch-hunt claim as woman loses key Aberdeenshire role

Councillors oust critic of Trump golf resort

By Gillian Duncan

Published: 01/09/2010

An outspoken critic of Donald Trump's plans to build a £750million golf resort in the north-east has been ousted from a key local authority post.

Independent Debra Storr was removed as vice-chairwoman of Aberdeenshire Council’s Formartine area committee yesterday after councillors voted to have her replaced with immediate effect.

The unceremonious exit mirrors that of her friend Martin Ford, who was dumped as chairman of the infrastructure committee in November 2007 after using his casting vote to temporarily bunker Mr Trump’s dream of building “the world’s greatest golf course” at the Menie Estate near Balmedie.

Last night, Miss Storr claimed she had been the victim of a “witch hunt” – but Ellon and district member Rob Merson said fellow councillors had simply become frustrated with her behaviour. He called for the emergency vote at a meeting of the area committee, which debated planning applications related to Mr Trump’s development.

Miss Storr has been a long-standing opponent of the billionaire’s plans, and has had run-ins with security staff at the Menie site. She was once accused of harassment by the American businessman, who said she should be “ashamed" of herself for trying to “discredit" his plans.

Miss Storr told the committee yesterday she had received no comments or complaints about her role as vice-chairwoman and it was clear she was on the “wrong side of the political divide”.

But Mr Merson’s motion to replace her with Turriff and district member Alisan Norrie was carried by seven votes to two.

Speaking after her removal yesterday, Miss Storr said: “Councillor Merson didn’t even have the courtesy to warn me.

“Councillor Merson and colleagues who agreed with him seemed to be treating this as continuation of their vindictiveness for anyone who wishes to stand up for the rights of the Menie residents.

“It boils down very simply to the fact I do not support the Trump development. This is just pure, childish vindictiveness.”

Mr Ford, Miss Storr and follow Formartine member Paul Johnston quit the council’s ruling Liberal Democrat administration over the resort row, and have formed the Democratic Independent Group, with councillors Sam Coull and Mark Cullen.

Miss Storr has taken a leading role in the fight to stop compulsory-purchase orders being used against homeowners who do not want to make way for the golf course project.

Mr Trump has since been given permission to add four neighbouring properties – Mill of Menie, Menie Fishing Station, Hermit Point, and Leyton Cottage – to the plan, but the owners have so far refused to sell.

Mr Merson, who worked as an assistant to Alex Salmond when he was Banff and Buchan MP, said Miss Storr’s views on the Menie project were not behind his move. He said: “I tabled it because I felt I was speaking for most of the committee when I said I wasn’t satisfied with the comments made by Councillor Storr on a variety of issues. I did not think they were conducive to the vice-chairwoman of this committee.”

Mr Trump’s team declined to comment last night. Mr Trump’s proposals for two golf courses, 500 houses, 950 holiday homes and a five-star hotel were approved after a public inquiry.

Mr Salmond’s minority SNP government called in the plans after Mr Ford threw them into turmoil.

Work is now well under way on what will be the championship course – which Mr Trump hopes will one day host golf’s Open Championship.

Reader's Comments

So much for Democracy. Go against the wishes of a council, you are evicted from your position. Now that is really good democracy. Smacks a little of Dictatorship. My way or you are out. What a way to run a council. Surely a councilor is allowed to have a different opinion from the rest of the sheep. No doubt Trump will be pleased that another of his little fleas as been squashed. For Aberdeenshire council to give him the go ahead to have the other plots, show how much contempt they have for their constituents.
minnie mo
Report this comment

"Work is now well under way on what will be the championship course – which Mr Trump hopes will one day host golf’s Open Championship." Nonsense - Have any P and J reporters been up there to have a look? I have and can report that very little work has been done since the diggers were supposedly to roll in about 3 months ago. I have made the following website to chart progress - http://myweb.tiscali.co.uk/balnagask/meniewebsite/ Maybe the P and J should do something similar to keep us all informed.
peter robinson
Report this comment

See what happens when you don't bleat along with the rest of the sheep? Baa, baa, baa......
M Torrance
Report this comment

I used to think that our councillors were in this for themselves and Mr Trump, now I am convinced of it. They are trying to silence anyone who is on the side of of we the voters, god help us all of they succeed.
Christina Crosley
Report this comment

Aberdeenshire council take heed - the rise of Nazi Germany started in a very similar way to the way some of them are behaving now. They ought to be ashamed of themselves. What price democracy?
dorothy bothwell
Report this comment

So anyone who disagrees with those who support Ms Storr are wrong - and likened to Nazis are we - we, the electorate, are not stupid. WHO wants heaps off sand dunes and birds when there is no work for young people - only the most blinkered, selfish, smug, I am OK Jack types, thats who. Bring on the development ASAP.
Bill Bright
Report this comment

It's outrageous. None of those other councillors have lifted a finger to represent the Menie residents, and clearly this move is an attempt to punish Debra Storr for doing so. Even the P&J have made the obvious link between her dismissal and the Trump development, and spelled it out in big letters on the front page. All that has happened is that 7 councillors have now made themselves look weak, ignorant, and as though they are comfortably in Trump's back pocket where they will be assuredly looked after. If they think it will have any impact on Debra Storr's commitment to representing the interests of the Menie residents and exposing the dirty tactics of Trump, I am certain they will be very quickly disappointed.
Runcible the Fatuous
Report this comment

The smell of corruption gets worse - the loser being democracy, what's been in it for the councillors?
William Hindley
Report this comment

Shocking? Definitely. Surprising? Hardly. Smacks of corruption on every level by "our" council. Why do we pander to this American bully? He treats us like backwater hillbillies and bulldozes his wishes through the council in much the same way he wants to bulldoze through peoples homes. Come on city and shire, stand up for the people that elected you useless lot into power.
IAN GRANT
Report this comment

Must be the shortest application of Godwin's Law ever!!! Well done Dorothy!! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_law
Sandy Milne
Report this comment

I presume you wrote that comment whilst dressed in your SS jacket, stockings and high heels eh Sandy?
Jo Butler
Report this comment

Jo, is that a Gestapo leather jacket that Ms Storr is wearing? 2 down 3 to go.
Sandy Milne
Report this comment

Well we can see just who is on the side of democracy. Certainly not any of the councils. Wave a bit of money at them and they fall about all over the place. Can't do enough for the money. We have been hearing plenty for the past few years about this "Greatest Ever Golf Course". Where is it then, should be nearly completed by now. The council has not held it up, and the plots that the council has gracioucly handed over to Trump without any thought of the occupiers. The golf course was well planned and passed by the council Without these plots. But greedy Mr Trump wanted them to add a bit more to HIS land. Did the council see fit to say No because the tenants were their constituents. Now they are only too happy to sack anyone who opposes their wishes or rather Mr Trumps wishes. As for a Gestapo jacket Sandy, with your comments you would suit it very well.
minnie mo
Report this comment

what is with all the children's comments. A hand Full of objections compaired to thousands of local aberdeenshire folk who want this development. Dorothy, how can you compare this to nazi's, nazi's murdered, slaughtered people because of religulous veiws. Not about a local constituant. i work in the oil and gas industry. am not on good money but i work hard. our industry is running down fast and in the not too distant future our little part of the work will need developments like this bring money to our doors. what is there to object about green grass and locals making money from rich wigs??? get a grip of your selfs and think for a change.
STEPHEN THOM
Report this comment

what is with all the children's comments. A hand Full of objections compaired to thousands of local aberdeenshire folk who want this development. Dorothy, how can you compare this to nazi's, nazi's murdered, slaughtered people because of religulous veiws. Not about a local constituant. i work in the oil and gas industry. am not on good money but i work hard. our industry is running down fast and in the not too distant future our little part of the work will need developments like this bring money to our doors. what is there to object about green grass and locals making money from rich wigs??? get a grip of your selfs and think for a change.
STEPHEN THOM
Report this comment

what is with all the children's comments. A hand Full of objections compaired to thousands of local aberdeenshire folk who want this development. Dorothy, how can you compare this to nazi's, nazi's murdered, slaughtered people because of religulous veiws. Not about a local constituant. i work in the oil and gas industry. am not on good money but i work hard. our industry is running down fast and in the not too distant future our little part of the work will need developments like this bring money to our doors. what is there to object about green grass and locals making money from rich wigs??? get a grip of your selfs and think for a change.
STEPHEN THOM
Report this comment

am sorry i dont know why that sent 3 times
STEPHEN THOM
Report this comment

If it is for the greater good of the community then we must respect our duly elected councillor’s decisions & must not stand in the way of progress.
Alan Hadley
Report this comment

Stephen don't hit the refresh button. Exit the article and come back in again.
Sandy Milne
Report this comment

Alan, are you saying that if the council makes a decision then it must be the correct one. That seems to be a bit far fetched. These coucilors are ordinary people, not super human, so therefore do not know everything, and are not alwasys right. That is why we are a democratic country to be allowed difference of opinions and not just go by what our councilors or govenrments say as being 100% correct. As for if it is for the greater good, that again is a subject for conjecture.
minnie mo
Report this comment

Bill Bright and "Joe Bloggs" (why the pseudonym?) -- if you are so keen for this development to proceed, I suggest that you send £100 (or more if you want...) to "Bugsy" Malone to help pay for the legal costs of enforcing the CPOs, and tell us when you've done so...
Bill Harrison
Report this comment

Mr Harrison - I am as entitled to my views as you are to yours. I happen to support the development instead of looking at sand dunes and birds for another 200 years. CPO`s may b used and tough luck if they are - people will b well paid - and on another subject would u spend all day admiring the view of some current properties in that area?????? wonderful are they not!!!!!!! fairly helps the area.
Bill Bright
Report this comment

Bill B, am in no way a tree hugger ; but your views on jobs for young folks are a bit flawed - if you wanted a job badly enough in Abdn, it's there for the taking, unfortunately theres a culture now of can't be ersed, also local people are not really into the 'service' thing -we all know very well that all this enteprise will attract is a number of seasonal workers (more Poles ?) maybe a nice transition from the berry picking - am sure the dunes can be maintained though and golf still played ? it's not a factory after all - guess public access being the problemo
Tavish Calgary
Report this comment

Well said Bill and Stephen (3 times!). All of this infantile commentary about democracy, corruption, dictatorship and Nazis would be hilarious if it wasn't so embarrassing. Good riddance to yet another these marginalised people who want to get in the way of progress - any progress - in the region, spoiling things for the majority. Can we now dispense with this road sense bunch of fools and start on our bypass please.........
Andy Johnston
Report this comment

To all you CPO fans -- we'll see you in court: The High Court, The European Court of Human Rights (which has a 46-year backlog of cases according to Wikipedia), the World Court... (But before that you'll probably need to elect a pro-CPO majority of local councillors).
Bill Harrison
Report this comment

Interesting view of democracy in the posts above. The populous elect the Councillors by voting, the Councillors who were elected chose who they wish to give positions of responsibility to, by voting. Then when someone disagrees with the outcome, they say its not democratic!
Getcha Faxwright
Report this comment

James Strachan- You seem to pop up from time tyo time with spurious unfounded allegations such as you made against me in a recent comment http://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/Article.aspx/1888948?UserKey= but when I challenged you to produce evidence to support your spurious and unfounded allegations you did not reply. Once again I issue a challenge to you to produce evidence to support your unfounded allegation against Councillor Merson and the ones you made against me. I don't suppose you have the courage or strength of character to identify yourself either. If you do have such evidence, get it out into the open. If you don't, hang your head in shame!! Allan Hendry
Jock Hendry
Report this comment

Debra Storr and Martin Ford are two of the most respected and regarded Councillors we have in north east Scotland. Not only do the people of Aberdeenshire think this but Martin Ford was nominated for a Scottish award. Donald Trumps golf resort is not wanted by the people of Aberdeenshire, tourists or golfers.
Sean Ashley
Report this comment

Sean Ashley. Well said, Trump has only got a track record of Bankruptcies behind him
dylan dougal
Report this comment

S Ashley where have you been, the majority of the N/East, golfers and tourists do want the resort, and D Storr where voted in as party electorate, not individuals, these members have chosen to voice their own opinions over that of their electorates. But time will tell as soon the public will have their votes again, will they get re-elected or not, as soon as these members changed their party elegance/party they should have given their constituents the vote, my view the sooner these councillors are changed and the party that i voted for in the previous election are bought back in the better. I am a supporter of this development, i also think there is more to the CPO's than is printed, whether i am in favour of the CPO's i am unsure. I do think there was and still is a better solution to CPO's. But in my view Aberdeen/shire need this and many more developments like this in order to survive the future economic climate. But whether you are for or against we are all entitled to our own opinions, and each opinion should be respected without this ill feeling that seem to creep into these some of these comments.
Neil Fraser
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.