Argyll unites to share £9bn turbines gains

By Rita Campbell

Published: 02/09/2010

Communities in Argyll are working together to ensure they get maximum benefit from three proposed offshore windfarm sites which could bring up to £9billion of investment to the county.

Companies have been given permission to survey the sites off Tiree, Islay and Machrihanish.

And local energy trusts from each area have come together to form the body Argyll Renewables Communities (Arc).

George Dean, an Arc volunteer from Islay with a corporate background, gave a presentation to councillors of the Mid Argyll, Kintyre and Islay local area community planning group at Campbeltown yesterday.

Mr Dean said: “These projects are enormous. These are projects that are beyond all of our understanding in terms of scale. If all of these projects happen it will be between £7-9billion capital investment, which would build the new Forth Road Bridge two times over.

“If only 20% of the maintenance for the Islay project is based on Islay it will add up to 20% to the gross value of Islay’s economy.

“We are working together to share ideas about offshore windfarms in these places to maximise the benefits and minimise whatever the negative impacts might be. We want to be active to see if we can influence developers and regulators for the benefit of all.”

Arc has told the Scottish Government that the decision-making process for the offshore windfarms should consider the onshore impacts on local communities.

Mr Dean said: “You don’t want to have a windfarm on your doorstep out of which you get no economic benefit. We have to persuade planning and licensing authorities that they should take these matters into account.

“We have to look at what it means in terms of economic opportunities locally. How many jobs is it going to create? What sort of jobs will it create? How do we get developers and the Scottish Government to invest in these communities to ensure they are prepared for economic development? We want to explain to developers it will be better for them to do that. We want them to be more open about what they are going to do, to be more specific about what skills they are going to need.”

Islay-based councillor Robin Currie said he wanted to ensure the communities got as many benefits as possible out of the situation and asked that the developments be made a standing issue on the area committee agenda.

This was agreed with Kintyre-based councillor Rory Colville saying: “This is possibly the most important issue that will affect Argyll in the next 100 years.”

Reader's Comments

George Dean is either an eejit(the P&J would not let me use id***) or he is suffering a mental blackout if he thinks that these windfarms will be a benefit to anyone in Scotland. The bottom line is that we are paying for them through our electricity bills. The developers get double ROC's for offshore wind and are supported by the likes of RBS who are also spending our money. We already have grid instability caused by these things and the wind companies are now being paid to switch them off. This wind madness has to stop before the lights go out and Scotland is bankrupted.
Ben Palmer
Report this comment

If anyone is "suffering a mental blackout" it is Ben Palmer, who clearly hasn't read the piece with any degree of care, and clearly saw the word windfarm and decided to sound off his views about them and to indulge in totally unnecessary name-calling. Had he not suffered this "blackout", he might have realised that George Dean was neither advocating nor condemning these offshore windfarms, but just explaining what they might mean to the communities involved, thus “We are working together to share ideas about offshore windfarms in these places to maximise the benefits and minimise whatever the negative impacts might be. We want to be active to see if we can influence developers and regulators for the benefit of all.” There seems litle chance that these massive wind factories won't go ahead so the local communities are doing their best to prepare their collective stance in advance. I wonder whether Ben Palmer lives on either of the islands affected or Kintyre. If not, then perhaps he should consider those people who do and who will be significantly affected by these developments.
Malcolm Ogilvie
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.