independence referendum

Postponing plans until after election

Published: 06/09/2010

NEWS that the Scottish Government may scrap plans to hold a referendum on independence before next year’s elections will come as a blow to fundamentalists but be a blessed relief to the rest of the electorate.

The result of the last Scottish election, and just about every opinion poll since, shows that while the Scottish National Party’s minority administration has been a qualified success, the appetite for moves towards independence has not grown significantly.

No matter how the arithmetic stacks up, there is a stubborn majority for whom independence is not top of their agenda.

It is wise for the SNP to put off a referendum on the issue until after the next election. The bill to approve the poll would never get through the parliament and there is not enough of a groundswell, or any at all in fact, calling for a vote to be held.

Mr Salmond wants to make the issue a central one in next May’s election campaign. This is a bold move considering the temptation to downplay the issue in favour of the government’s overall performance must be tempting.

The SNP, however, exists to campaign for independence and it performs at its most united and best when arguing this most inexhaustible of topics.

There should be a commitment, though, to a fixed timescale for a referendum after the election and clear direction as to what will happen depending on the outcome of the vote.

Mr Salmond knows that he can take his dream forward with confidence and authority only if he has a renewed and strengthened mandate.

Reader's Comments

There is every likelihood that the SNP will win a second term in Holyrood. Labour and The LibDems have dicredited themselves and The Tories are despised in Scotland. Whatever the outcome, it is only fair that the electorate are allowed to give their views by referendum on fiscal autonomy or independence. The Unionist parties bring themselves into disrepute by blocking it. Let the people have their say!
Ron Campbell
Report this comment

The SNP are right to do this. They are committed, as we know, to ensuring that a referendum on independence takes place. Tabling the bill now would guarantee that it could not take place. Therefore, they need to wait until it becomes possible to put the referendum into place, and then do so. Of course, if that day comes and they do not pursue it because they fear they will lose the referendum, that will be a different matter...
Runcible the Fatuous
Report this comment

We should probably seek Grampian independence more than Scottish. If we are to believe ACC our financial problems are caused by a grant system that favours the central belt. Perhaps a Grampian Independence movement to free Pictland. We should try to form borders North of Dundee and South of Peterhead to avoid drug addicts. In fact Torry could form an independent state and offer tax haven status for residents. Might be difficult competing in international football though. Might be able to beat Faroe or even Lichtenstein.
Alan Craigie
Report this comment

Alan we can't even beat the Faeroe islands as it is, then again we're to busy paying for the New Wembley. Vote SNP and for independence, after independence, vote for who ever you want.
alan reid
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.