Pupils forced to pay for classes

By Gillian Bell

Published: 06/09/2008

Aberdeen City Council has been forced to charge standard grade and higher music students for instrumental lessons.

It is understood the move has led to some pupils dropping the subject, as their parents cannot afford to pay.

Calum Clark, a 16-year-old fifth-year pupil at Bridge of Don Academy, said he plans to launch a campaign against the new policy, which affects dozens of pupils. He said his family can afford the new charges of £8 for a group lesson and £10 for an individual lesson outwith class time, but others may not.

A letter written by city council music co-ordinator Ken McLeod and sent to parents says that all departments are being asked to make savings “to deal with a large deficit in the budget for 2008/09”.

As a result, anyone not already on a music course as of August 18 of this year will have to pay for lessons outwith class time.

Calum, of Keir Heights, Balmedie, said: “They can’t learn their pieces if they don’t get lessons. The only way I was able to pass my standard grades was by having lessons.”

He said he is planning to organise a petition to protest against the “injustice” of the move.

Neighbouring local authority, Aberdeenshire Council, already charges students for music lessons, except those entitled to free school meals.

It also runs a discount scheme for families who have either two or three children receiving lessons.

A spokesman for Aberdeen City Council said teaching music is not a statutory obligation and the move saves the council from having to downgrade the service or even scrap it altogether.

Reader's Comments

Is this now a free service- I took music lessons over 20 years ago when I was at school and my parents had to pay for them.
Karen Urquhart
Report this comment

Aberdeen City council have not been forced to charge music students they chose to charge them. They've spent the money they used to spend on music lessons somewhere else. Posh new offices perhaps, feasability studies for new football stadiums who knows. But abismal writing aside, they have definitely not been forced!
Alan Craigie
Report this comment

The statement that Aberdeenshire charges for lessons is not quite correct. My daughter has just taken Higher Music at an Aberdeenshire school, having started playing an instrument in P6 through the school. We paid for the lessons until she began the Standard Grade course, after which the lessons were free.
Sarah King
Report this comment

Sarah King - I'm so glad you posted your comment - I'm the mother of Calum Clark the teenager trying to make the point and yet the newspaper has ignored the facts - ABerdeenshire council don't charge standard and higher grade students but Aberdeen City coucil are. I tried to post a comment detailing this yesterday but the moderator obviously feels the can't show it - I wonder why poor reporting????
Debra Clark
Report this comment

Alan Craigie - we totally concur with your views - the articles in both the Evening Express and P&J have been poorly written - both newspapers were presented with the detail that Aberdeen City Coucil will now charge for lessons and pupils in Aberdeenshire undertaking Higher & Standard SQA course will continue to be exempt from charges - this misreporting of the facts does nothing to help the case of these young talented students and appears to show Aberdeen City Council following the same pathway as the shire - dismmal!
Debra Clark
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.