Four former presidents of NFU Scotland have officially come out in favour of a Yes vote in the forthcoming independence referendum.
The quartet – three Johns and a Jim – have been rumoured for months to be about to make their move but yesterday at a press conference in Yes campaign headquarters in Glasgow they firmly nailed their colours to the pro-independence mast.
John Cameron, John Kinnaird, John Ross and Jim Walker have between them 19 years of experience of leading Scotland’s main farming lobby group.
If there is a central theme to their argument it revolves around the belief that Scotland has been ill served in European Union negotiations by a succession of Defra Ministers.
Mr Walker asserted that these ministers were not independent operators and had since the 1990s been simply driven by a UK Treasury imperative to steadily cut back farm support.
Mr Ross said: “Scottish farming must resist any further diminution of influence and we cannot go into the future facing years of uncertainty.”
Mr Cameron was president of NFUS from 1978 to 1983 and has rarely been far away from the corridors of power in Brussels since then in various capacities.
He said: “We need our own representation in Brussels. Scotland is 85% Less Favoured Area and 15% Non- less Favoured Area. England is exactly the opposite and that makes Westminster politicians less likely to argue our case.”
Mr Kinnaird, pointing out that he was an arable farmer with beef, said he agreed. “Scotland’s voice is usually ignored. I am concerned about a backlash against Scotland if there is a No vote but be very clear – I do not see this as a vote for a political party.”
Asked where other former NFUS presidents stood on the matter Mr Walker immediately criticised George Lyon, former Lib Dem MEP, rapporteur on CAP reform in the European parliament and leader of Rural Better Together. “George was an interim NFUS president for a year before he became a politician. He has no track record and no experience of dealing with the EU as a farmer representative.”
Mr Walker also poured scorn on the suggestion that the group had no backing from the food processing and marketing sector.
“The market for Scottish produce will not stop the day after independence. Anyone who suggests that there is only a premium for Scottish products because we are part of the UK is talking rubbish,” he said.
Mr Ross, immediate past chairman of the Moredun Foundation took a similar view on research funding, much of which is currently UK funded.
“Research commissions will go to wherever there is first class research and I have no fears that we will attract funding in the future. A lot comes from outside the UK in any event,” he said.
All four were convinced that an independent Scotland would soon be back in the EU as a full Member State. According to Mr Walker it would be “within a year or two.”
Asked if there were any downsides envisaged Mr Ross said: “From the farming point of view I can see no negatives.”
Mr Cameron added: “Since devolution everything related to farming has been positive.”
Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs, Environment and Food, Richard Lochhead described yesterday’s move as “very significant”.
Panel –
John Ross CBE, from Portpatrick, Dumfries and Galloway is a livestock farmer. He was NFUS President between 1990 and 1996 and chairman of the Scotch Quality Beef and Lamb Association from 1997 to 2000. Between 2002 and 2012, he was chairman of Moredun Animal Diseases Research Institute and Foundation.
Dr John Cameron CBE, who farms at Balbuthie in Fife, became NFU Scotland’s first long-term president in 1978. During his term, the union was able to take an active long-term role in the affairs of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP). He was a member of the agricultural praesidium in Brussels for five years and was first chairman of the EEC Sheepmeat Committee. He is a past chairman of the QMS Standard Setting Committee for cattle and sheep and in 2015 he was made a Fellow of the Scottish Agricultural College.
Jim Walker, who graduated in accountancy from Edinburgh University, took over the family farm in the 1980s and now rears beef cattle and sheep on 3,500 acres near Sanquhar. He was chairman of Quality Meat Scotland from 2003 until 2005 following five years as President of NFU Scotland. He acted as a consultant to Robert Wiseman Dairies from 2003 until 2008 and joined Argent Energy in 2003 as Vice-Chairman, becoming Operations Director in 2005 and Managing Director in 2008.
John Kinnaird was Vice President of NFU Scotland from 2000 until 2003 and president from 2003 until 2007. He chaired the Scottish Government Review of Veterinary Surveillance, is a director of the Moredun Research Institute and a Fellow of the Royal Agricultural Societies. He is a partner in a 600 acre farm in East Lothian.