Plans for a 112ft wind turbine that would have powered a north-east farm and plant business have been thrown out.
The team at Miller Plant, Midmar wanted to build the mast to cut their energy costs, and to become more green.
But yesterday, members of the Garioch area committee heard concerns from local residents about the proximity of the turbine to their homes, and the possible knock-on problems of noise and shadow flicker.
One even claimed the issue was exacerbated as the site was in a low field surrounded by hills, making it a “natural amphitheatre”.
The committee narrowly agreed to refuse the application, despite calls for a deferral to find out more about some of the concerns raised.
Managing director of Miller Plant, Ian Miller, said last night he was “ very disappointed” at the decision and confirmed he would be appealing it.
During the meeting, councillors heard 59 letters of support and 37 objections had been lodged about the scheme.
Planning officer Bruce Strachan said the visual impact in the area would be “medium” and urged councillors to back it.
But objector Ian Wade said nearby residents would look directly on to the turbine, and that lights from Miller Plant’s yard would illuminate it further, and that, combined with the noise and risk of shadow flicker, would directly impact their amenity.
He also raised concerns that up to 3,000-5,000 geese flying to Loch Skene would be at risk if the turbine was built.
Councillor Sheena Lonchay moved to refuse the application, and said: “We have seen many sites for wind turbines but this is the first one where the turbine has been completely circled by residential properties in a small diameter.
“I do think it would have a significant impact on the general amenity of the houses.”
Councillor Amanda Allan seconded her motion, and said: “I do think there’s quite a lot of houses very close to this turbine that could potentially be affected. When you see the photo from the road, there’s houses across the road that are going to be looking directly at it.”
But Councillor Martin Ford argued the application should be deferred for further information about noise and shadow flicker, and described the turbine as “modest” in size. He was defeated five votes to four.