Islands MSPs are seeking clarity from the Scottish Government on how a more localised approach to Covid-19 restrictions might work if applied in the Northern and Western Isles.
Liam McArthur, Beatrice Wishart and Alasdair Allan, who represents Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles, have raised the issue with health secretary Jeane Freeman and Dr John Harden, the deputy national clinical director.
Mr McArthur said urgent discussions are taking place with island councils and health boards about the protocols that would need to be in place should a localised approach to restrictions be applied.
He has raised concerns that the most recent government guidance on students returning home takes no account of the needs of island students, who have to use public transport in the form of a plane or ferry.
Mr McArthur said: “I certainly appreciate that there are complex and sensitive balances that need to be struck in decisions around how restrictions apply. However, the proposed approach set out by the health secretary is one that seems sensible and pragmatic.
“It was also encouraging to hear Ms Freeman acknowledge that any protocols would have to take account of the fact that each of the island communities is different and that a one-size-fits-all approach would not be appropriate across all three island groups.
“None of this guarantees that a localised approach will be adopted in the coming weeks. However, it does at least allow for a more transparent and consultative process for arriving at decisions.”
Ms Wishart said it is important clear procedures are in place and ready should localised measures be adopted.
“Government and public health authorities have to make difficult decisions about the balance of coronavirus restrictions to control the spread of the virus and the impact of restrictions on wider society.
“Greater involvement of local government and local health boards in that decision making is key for public confidence, understanding and compliance.”
Mr Allan said the discussions need to examine how the approach to Covid-19 could best be ‘island proofed’ to ensure it works best in an island setting.
“While I understand the desire to loosen lockdown restrictions in areas with low case numbers, the outbreak in Uist has shown just how quickly the virus can spread in island communities.
“We need to remain vigilant and it is right that the Scottish Government takes a cautious approach when it comes to this issue.
A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: “The health secretary had a constructive meeting with islands MSPs where she was able to listen to their concerns.
“These restrictions, as with those applied earlier to parts of the West of Scotland, will be reviewed within three weeks from coming into force and further guidance will made available where necessary. The First Minister is engaging with and listening to a range of expert opinions, including elected representatives across Scotland, and decisions are made following consultation with them.
“Action – and adherence to – restrictions is needed now to safeguard lives and protect from infection.”
