INDEPENDENT FINANCIAL ADVICE ON MONEY MATTERS AROUND THE HIGHLANDS, ISLANDS & MORAY
Humans have a hard time being investors. Normally, we like to purchase things when they are cheap and avoid them when they are expensive, but that is often not the case for shares. We tend to get overly optimistic and enthusiastic when share markets rise dramatically, as they have done since the Global Financial Crisis a decade ago. Yet when markets fall materially, we feel bruised and cautious, seeking to hang onto our stable fixed interest holdings and even selling shares to avoid further falls in portfolio value. That’s rarely a good idea, especially if you do not need the bulk of your capital in the foreseeable future.
An adviser would normally seek to rebalance an investor’s portfolio on a regular basis, by which we mean returning it to the original target allocation that was initially agreed. Most often, over the past few years, rebalancing has meant selling growth assets (shares) and buying defensive assets (fixed interest) in a contrarian manner. This has helped to avoid the portfolio becoming dominated, over time, by the riskier growth assets component of the portfolio and to keep the investor within their emotional tolerance for falls, financial capacity to weather them and their need to take risk in the first place.
Logically, the reverse also applies; at times like these the proportion of shares in an investor’s portfolio will have fallen below their long-term target. This matters as their portfolio now has too little risk and it will be harder for the growth assets remaining to recoup the falls in value when markets eventually recover.
We can work that idea through with a simple example. Imagine you own a £10,000 portfolio split 50% (£5,000) into growth assets and 50% into defensive assets. In the growth assets portion, you own 50 units of a global equity fund priced at £100 per unit. Growth assets fall by 40%. Let’s assume your defensive assets are unchanged in value. You still own 50 global equity fund units, but they are now priced at £60. Your growth-defensive split has moved from 50/50 to 37.5/62.5. Time to rebalance.
Figure 1: Market falls leave you underweight growth assets
Rebalancing i.e. buying equities to realign the portfolio with its allocation target, helps to ensure a quicker recovery back to where you started. This is because the breakeven price of your equity holdings is now lower.
So, let’s now assume that you rebalance by taking £1,000 from your defensive assets and buying growth assets to get you back to a 50/50 split (left hand grid below). You can buy 16.7 units at £60 with the £1,000 raised. To get your portfolio back to its starting value of £10,000 your now 66.7 global equity units need to rise 50% to £90 per unit (middle grid). However, an un-rebalanced portfolio (right hand grid) only rises to £9,500 with this 50% rise. In fact, to get back to a portfolio value of £10,000 and un-rebalanced portfolio requires a rise of 67% in the global equity units to £100.
Figure 2: Rebalancing helps the portfolio to recover faster
Even if the markets fall again after rebalancing, the opportunity exists to rebalance again, likewise further reducing the rate of return required to get back to where you were compared to un-rebalanced portfolios. That takes courage and discipline when your emotions are telling you to do the opposite!
A good independent financial adviser will be able to guide you.
James Sinclair FPFS is a Chartered Financial Planner at Achieve Financial Planning Ltd, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Next Money Matters topic is on ‘Retirement and beyond’
Your Local to Highlands, Islands and Moray Contributors – Click to visit their website.