former principal hands back his honorary degree in protest at gesture

RGU’s Trump accolade angers academic

By Rebecca Buchan

Published: 29/09/2010

The first principal of Robert Gordon University handed back his honorary degree yesterday – to protest against the decision to give Donald Trump a similar accolade.

David Kennedy said he was “appalled” by plans to acknowledge the billionaire businessman and accused RGU of making the gesture to try to secure large donations.

Mr Trump is building the “world’s greatest golf course” at the Menie Estate at Balmedie in Aberdeenshire.

But the £750million project has been opposed by green campaigners and some locals who are refusing to sell their homes to make way for the development.

One of them, David Milne, of Hermit Point, accompanied Mr Kennedy as he made his protest yesterday.

Mr Kennedy received his honorary degree 11 years ago after serving as principal of RGU from 1987 to 1997 and overseeing its elevation to university status.

He walked through RGU’s main entrance at Aberdeen’s Schoolhill yesterday afternoon, carrying his certificate with the words “not wanted” written across it in black ink.

The university will honour New York-based Mr Trump for his entrepreneurship next week.

But Mr Kennedy said there were many more entrepreneurs in the Aberdeen area more worthy of recognition. He added: “Universities up and down the land are all strapped for cash, they're all looking to raise money, and RGU may well be looking for that money from Donald Trump.

“I think the degree has been given in the hope of receiving some money back in return.”

A spokesman for RGU rejected the accusation and added: “The university has already been involved with the Trump Organisation, including our design students producing a tartan for the company.

“Practical projects such as this, where our students engage with a client, are all part of the student experience and we hope that this award will help forge links that will benefit our students.”

Mr Trump will receive an honorary doctorate at a ceremony on October 8.

Earlier this week Mr Kennedy sent a letter to RGU’s acting principal, Professor John Harper, which said: “Honorary degrees are to people who are of some distinction, who are honourable people who have commanded a wide respect because of the service they have given. I don't think Donald Trump fits any of those criteria.”

Prof Harper was not available yesterday afternoon to meet Mr Kennedy so the degree was handed back to one of RGU’s vice-principals.

A spokesman for RGU said: “We are disappointed he has felt the need to return his degree, particularly given his past connections and major contribution to the development of the university.”

Last night, Ryan Maclean president of the Robert Gordon Student Association, said: “I would like to state that there is widespread support among the student body for the conferral of the honorary award to Mr Trump.

“We identify with the reasons for this conferral, and are pleased that the university has chosen to recognise Mr Trump's entrepreneurial spirit and investment in the region.”

Reader's Comments

At last. Someone of integrity has stood up and been counted.
Ron Campbell
Report this comment

A true man of his word
Robert Horne
Report this comment

Look at how the Business School has developed since his departure and you might understand this mans understanding of the world of business.
Missing You
Report this comment

Still getting to grips with "Dr Trump". I want one too. I could easily become a self important arrogant monster, but that would be easy, like I say..Missing you, can you digress?
manniewe naeclue
Report this comment

And the honoured one, may in future, bestow some benefaction. A mercenary but unprincipled calculation.
Michty Me
Report this comment

Ooh, the students ave been involved in a practical project for my organiation. Can I expect a doctorate too? I think it would be easier to dismiss this if it were someone else, but a former principal of the university? Fair to say he knows a bit about the workings...
Michael Hodgson
Report this comment

This day and age Doctorates, OBE's, MBE's, and even Knighthoods have been handed out left right and centre. Donald Trump for all his faults has succeeded in terms of business where all others have failed, like it or not. His personal choices(dodgy barnet)however and such quotes in referal to the project in Balmedie "great doons of Scatland" has given us all a great scource of amusement. RGU has moved on leaps and bounds from the days of David Kennedy, as has the way business is conducted. Are many people going to lose any sleep over Mr Kennedy handing back his doctorite? not me for one. I do find it strange that in times when Ricky Hatton gets castigated over his drug use yet when Elton John whom recieved his Knighthood many years ago people seemed to forget he was a hard drug user himself years before that, role model I don't think so. Even this week it had emerged that Bono's charity for 3rd world causes raised £10 million yet little over £100k found its way to Africa. The rest was spent on salaries/perks and jollies for for the staff. Yet despite this Bono is still seen as a Saint, and yet people have parted with their hard earned cash to donate to this cause. The point I am getting at whilst Donald Trump has not broken the law nor interfered with any kids, murdered anyone yet he has been villified by the keyboard hardmen/women online as well as by local councillors all of whom are all to willing to call him names and level all sorts of accusations. The Stuart Milnes, Ian Woods and Donald Trumps will never be popular, whilst they don't make the most popular choices they succeed in terms of business. I'd rather look towards the likes of them for inspiration in terms of business accumen rather than the Debra Storrs or Martin Fords of this world. For gods sake folks its only a bit of paper get real!
niall clark
Report this comment

An undignified cheap publicity stunt.
Lawrence Fraser
Report this comment

Amen to niall clark. Could,nt have put it better myself. Mr. Kennedy is past his sell by date and it shows. What did he do to put Aberdeen on the world map.
gran riviera
Report this comment

Donald Trump is an international businessman of much renown. RGU would like to be an international university of renown. Ergo why the fuss over this award. Mainly because we have a noisy but insignificant group of sandal wearing beardies who don't want the city or area to develop either physically or economically. These people would seem to want every area in Aberdeenshire to remain either an unvisited nature reserve or some sort of monument to the Victorians. And we have seen this time and time again in the arguments over the trump development, the bypass,the airport extension and of course in the development of UT gardens. Most people from Aberdeen want the Trump development to go ahead because it will be a massive boost to the local economy and for local tourism. Local people also want to see Aberdeen to continue to develop towards a modern fully functioning city with bigger opportunities for all due to a stronger and more diverse economy. Unfortunately for the beardies, of whom the former principal is obviously one, they just can't accept that the modern vision has won. So despite continuing futile gestures and made-up furore we will have a world class golf development, we will have some city centre redevelopment and we will have a bypass. It's just a pity that the P&J keeps giving these people the oxygen of publicity.
Duncan Massey
Report this comment

This 'Tripping up Trump' group are getting beyond a joke. Has this man never been involved in the handing out of honorary degree to anyone that in which at least some people question? Probably! Secondly, it is 'honorary' no one has studied hard for their degree it is handed out like sweets and means nothing. Finally, the member that stole the reporters phone should have been charged as that is theft under Scots Law. They the campaign group should not be above the law!
Doug Donaldson
Report this comment

Duncan, "a massive boost to the local economy and for local tourism". That is just fantasy, just have a look oot the window, its cold, wet and windy, there will never be significant "resort" at Mennie. There will be, in time, a large housing scheme, paid for, not by Trump, but by the punters who invest in the houses.
Michty Me
Report this comment

It's interesting to note that those who criticise Dr Kennedy can't spell and can only use basal language by insulting him. Dr Kennedy has more integrity in his pinkie that the likes of D. Massey! ansd the self styled Gran Rivierva who doesnt even have the guts to tell us who he is? We live in a democracy, it is everyone's right to return their honours - it is one of the few ways of legitimate protest. What is interesting is that at the end of the day, Donald Trump, Ian Wood, D. Massey, D. Donaldson and Michty Me as well as the self styled Gran Riviera, will all be eaten by worms - they are not as immortal as they would have us believe!!!!!!!!!
John Scott
Report this comment

It always makes me chuckle when I read the word "resort". Has anyone looked outside their windows today?
Dasbo B
Report this comment

Good to see that RGU Students association is still a throbbing hub of radical thought and student rebellion...
Iain Connell
Report this comment

John Scott, the critics of Dr Kennedy are entitled to an opinion, that is the basic fundamentals of a democracy. I've read comments on this article over the last few months with interest. You quoted "It's interesting to note that those who criticise Dr Kennedy can't spell and can only use basal language by insulting him. Dr Kennedy has more integrity in his pinkie that the likes of D. Massey! ansd the self styled Gran Rivierva who doesn't even have the guts to tell us who he is?". Yet it is another example of cyber bullying and insults conducted by the TUT, as recently as yesterday Fiona Hardie(niece of Micheal Forbes) was reported to have stolen a phone from a journalist. If you are going to criticise people for bad grammar and spelling, then start with some of the protesters on here that use the basal language and bad spelling as you suggest. I read Duncan Massey's comments and whilst he doesn't bring it across to your standards he makes very valid points, to criticise him on this contradicts yourself when you quoted that we live in a democracy. Everyone is entitled to an opinion no matter how much we like what we hear. We in the North East of Scotland have to evolve if we are to sustain business and investment for our future, after all there is no bottomless pit at the bottom of the North Sea. To build for the future we need a decent infrastructure and whilst projects such as UTG, the city bypass, arena stadium and the “great doons” golf course at Balmedie may not be everyone's cup of tea, but they are vital to our economy if we are to attract future investment for the greater good.
niall clark
Report this comment

Quite right that Dr Kennedy handed back his honorary degree, who would have anything to do with a University that gave a degree to a toss pot like Trump. The next thing we will see is that the University will be giving an honorary degree to Criminals, Murderers and even Alex Salmond, Kenny MacAskill, Gordon Brown, Tony Blair and how about one to Peter Mandelson, who resigned numerous times from the corrupt labour party, and came back numerous times to be found out about further gerrymandering he had been involved in. I think students should consider going to this University to study anything, unless they are going into a career of crime, fraud, corruption and business maladministration. This University is now more suited to supporting the most despicable low life in the country, and anyone employing someone that had qualified here should think seriously about the ability they may have, considering the quality and probity of those running the University. 99.999% of Solicitors give the others a bad name.
Peter Wilson
Report this comment

Whatever the merits of Trump's proposed course/resort, the fact of the matter is that it is a very long way from completion. To confer an honorary degree at this stage, therefore, is questionable. It is of course bogus to suggest that this honour is purely for Trump's acument elsewhere, it is evident that his involvement in the North East is behind it. So why now? Is the lesson to RGU students that you don't have to complete to succeed? An idea expressed is an idea delivered, one and the same? It's a very poor lesson. One that reflects on RGU, sadly for them.
Richard Fraser
Report this comment

Michty me. I am pretty sure that it also rains in Wales. Typically more than here. However, judging by the fact that the Celtic Manor 'resort' is hosting the Ryder Cup this week it doesn't seemed to have hindered them unduly.
Duncan Massey
Report this comment

Where were the TUT when Trump gave that monies to the family in Balmedie regarding their disables son? Maybe they did not think that was a genuine offer or were busy knitting more jumpers. J. Scott do not suppose what is going to happen to me at the end times as I have a faith that is strong despite comments by man!
Doug Donaldson
Report this comment

Peter Wilson, rather strong yet repetitive words there, if your going to have some reasoned input in to this debate could you please add something new? Having read your comments its like having a broken record as you tend to repeat yourself over and over again.
niall clark
Report this comment

Peter Wilson, rather strong yet repetitive words there, if your going to have some reasoned input in to this debate could you please add something new? Having read your comments its like having a broken record as you tend to repeat yourself over and over again.
niall clark
Report this comment

I think this is about our definition or perception of that word "resort". There will be a golf course and probably a modest hotel at Mennie but there are numerous golf courses and hotels in the North East. It's just not economically significant and cannot justify all the hype.
Michty Me
Report this comment

Peter Wilson, rather strong yet repetitive words there, if your going to have some reasoned input in to this debate could you please add something new? Having read your comments its like having a broken record as you tend to repeat yourself over and over again.
niall clark
Report this comment

Duncan Massey, it is clear from the above photograph that Mr Kennedy doesn't have a beard.
Alasdair Johnston
Report this comment

Duncan Not a single one of Trump's golf courses anywhere in the world can even make it into the top 100! What makes you so sure he will somehow deliver the goods with this one?
Alastair Naughton
Report this comment

To all those in favour of the Trump development: I am reliably informed by a lecturer at RGU that EVERY SINGLE rule in the book has been broken to get Trump to where he is now with this project. How does that sit with "honour", "giving service to the community" or setting a good role model for students?
Alastair Naughton
Report this comment

he could be wearing sandals though alasdair, you can't tell..
Ved M
Report this comment

"This University is now more suited to supporting the most despicable low life in the country, and anyone employing someone that had qualified here should think seriously about the ability they may have, considering the quality and probity of those running the University" Oh Peter, go sit in the corner, have a nice cup of sweet tea then go get a life! How on earth can you tar every single graduate from RGU with the same brush by saying they are not fit to be employed? How many of the tree huggers that are against Trumps development are graduates of RGU? Do you think their ideas and support are worthless as well?
Colin Hossack
Report this comment

Doug: wake up and see the donation to the family with the disabled son for what it is - the most cynical PR stunt of the lowest kind. This is not to dispute the needs of the family one iota. We can all see the needs perfectly clearly, and I like to think I can really empathise with them. You can bet your last cent however that Trump cares not one jot about the family. This is simply a PR stunt, at a cost of what amounts to small change for him. Ably assisted by the P&J and EE as ever.
Alastair Naughton
Report this comment

Ved, good point. Despite the clean shaven appearance and the fact that he's wearing a tie it is of course possible that he is wearing sandals thereby invalidating any point he was trying to make. I wonder if anyone in the Press & Journal made a note of his footwear?
Alasdair Johnston
Report this comment

Doug Donaldson would you be able to sign an affadavit that your post is that of a genuine 'member of the public' or are you being paid for your post, either directly, as a professional PR scribe, or indirectly, through your place of employment?
Graham Slater
Report this comment

Who cares all the universities give out these pieces of paper to film stars, pop stars, what does it matter, of course it is good for the universities with publicity etc. Mr Kennedy has stong views and he is entilted to do what he wants, but to be so bitter, i think it comes with old age, i should know.
bob seivwright
Report this comment

How unfortunate that Robin Harper would snub a man of Dr Kennedy's standing. The top job appointments panel at RGU are surely looking for a candidate who can meld Town and Gown and avoid politicising and demeaning the varsity.
Graham Slater
Report this comment

There are other businessmen/women in this world to look up to, to aspire to…But not trump or Wood…Unless of course you aspire to be an Ubber capitalist, who has no regards for local laws and country wide environmental laws (which only stand in the way of the profit.) It is possible to be a capitalist, make loads of cash and not have to resort to bullying tactics or blackmail. But unfortunately Duncan Massey seems to think that these are examples to follow. I fear for our children! We live in a society where we have allowed a form of capitalism that has no regard for people, corporations are obliged by law to make profit for the shareholders, which is a good thing but it should be done ethically and with regards for laws that govern the country and its people. To many times now these are blatantly abused and broken, not only by the people who run these institutions but by our elected leaders. I for one welcome progress but it must be done in such a way that everyone benefits. No one should be so naive in the 21st century to believe that the people running these corporations are putting people first, no matter how good their PR is or how fluffy they try to make themselves out to be. Their first and foremost concern (and they are obliged by law to do this) is to make profit. Yes, some money might filter into the local economy but most will not. Traders who open up in Truptoon will get charged for the privilege or be owned by his parent company. Most jobs available will be part time or short term contracts (no employee benefits) which will not deliver long term security for his employees. Any one with half a brain knows that this is how all business is conducted these days. So, some benefit will come but just not as much as promised. p.s. I don’t have a beard nor do I play golf yet I don’t object to the scheme out of hand, I just object to how the corporate machine works these days and how out political leaders can dip in and out of the democratic process we have in this country at their choosing.
lee gordon
Report this comment

G Slater I do not work for anyone and merely have views about this area and the going on that at times gets petty.
Doug Donaldson
Report this comment

What a joke RGU recognising and honouring the biggest example of enviromental vandalism in the North East.
Al Noble
Report this comment

What a joke RGU recognising and honouring the biggest example of enviromental vandalism in the North East.
Al Noble
Report this comment

Yes you're quite right grannie riviera, you couldn't put it better than anyone. Doug D, yes yes yes yes yes, why of course sir, why even ask sir? Its yours sir. BTW, I wasn't totally against this course in the begining, I am now though. Someone said here they broke every rule in the book to get to this stage, that is old news but worth the reminding of. It still makes me cringe with anger. Doug D, thank god I'm a giver not a taker!
manniewe naeclue
Report this comment

Yes Al, well pointed to and for what? So a few "takers" get there kicks.
manniewe naeclue
Report this comment

What a joke RGU recognising and honouring the biggest example of enviromental vandalism in the North East.
Al Noble
Report this comment

What a joke RGU recognising and honouring the biggest example of enviromental vandalism in the North East.
Al Noble
Report this comment

pr stunt now smear tactics ah but no mention of land theft or trying to intimidate my father into handing over his inheritance from his dead uncle the truth is out there
mike forbes
Report this comment

Who cares? Some tree huggers? The NE has hundreds of miles of identical sand dunes! The wee birdies will surely find somewhere else to live. The beauty of sand dunes is that they are- errrmm - made of sand???? Ten years after maintenance stops they'll revert to being pretty much the same. As for the houses; the council would probably have given permission to some developer within the next 20 years anyway....
Ja R
Report this comment

Another TuT PR stunt, if David Kennedy wanted to hand back hits “honorary degree” that’s up to him, for someone who is supposedly respected yet is involved in simple minded tunnel versioned nuggets. I agree that Trump does not deserve this piece of paper! That’s all it is. I for one am looking forward to walking over the best golf course in the world. Laugh is i don’t like golf. I don’t work for the accused council. I dove down the mennie site and a lovely bit of land it is all bar 1 area which looks like a pig shed, i would not offer any money for it. 40ft conifer tree’s are cheaper!
STEPHEN THOM
Report this comment

Doug Donaldson, thank you for your clarification. I trust you appreciate that these columns are being targeted by 'on message', hired professional PR scribes, such as Gran Riviera.
Graham Slater
Report this comment


STEPHEN THOM
Report this comment


STEPHEN THOM
Report this comment

Before praising Trump it might be worthwhile looking at the numerous failures he's had around the world - who's to say Menie won't be one of a long line of failures? www.businessnightmares.co.uk/About_Business_Nightmares.html thebsreport.wordpress.com/.../another-trump-failure-resort-foldsinvestors-lose-millions/
John Scott
Report this comment

niall clark seems to be a bit of a know all as regards how businesses have moved on in 13 years. he claims that the university has moved on leaps and bound since 1997 when Dr Kennedy retired. That's some mighty big claims master clark is making. it's only a pity he has not provided one scrap of information/evidence to back up this claim. Of course budgets and others things have moved on, but in real terms let master clark put his evidence in a form which is open to scrutiny, if he can't then perhaps he should return to kindergarten and leave the big boys to their reasoned debate!
John Scott
Report this comment

niall clark do you work for the Wood Group or maybe you're an employee of AJL? You say others have the right to voice their comments but you seem to be only in favour if those comments accord with your views! Get a life min!
John Scott
Report this comment

niall clark, maybe you should check your facts before making nonsense statements. If you check out you will see that since 1999 the university has only moved from 59th place to 51st place according to the Times Good University Guide - hardly a great change. From 1993 - 1999 it moved from 83rd place to 59th place!
John Scott
Report this comment

niall clark, maybe you should check your facts before making nonsense statements. If you check out you will see that since 1999 the university has only moved from 59th place to 51st place according to the Times Good University Guide - hardly a great change. From 1993 - 1999 it moved from 83rd place to 59th place!
John Scott
Report this comment

John Scott, in the week since Dr Kennedy has decided to hand back his doctorate there hasn't exactly been a que of past recipients lining up to hand theirs back has there? From high profile recipients such as Sir Alex Ferguson, Neil Kinnock, Gordon Brown, Pamela Stephenson, Terry Waite, David Trimble,Ranulph Fiennes I could go on but if you have a little shred of intelligence you'd know where I am leading this to. These people I have mentioned are not exactly clamouring to hand back their degrees in disgust are they? Perhaps you should write to them yourself and lobby them to do the same as the Rt Hon Dr Kennedy? It seems that you have reduced yourself to the same infantile and basal language that you had earlier accused some other posters on here of. Do I work for the Wood group or AJL? not even close, your the kind of campaigner TUT needs given the behaviour on these forums. RGU has seen an increased pass rate as well as an intake in the last 10 years, as well as this a wider variety of courses that are on offer. I find you contradict yourself on many levels, do you offer proof that suggests I would work for AJL or Wood group? As for suggesting your in the "big boy" league in terms of debate I just about fell off my seat laughing having read your previous comments on a variety of matters. If your so enlightened perhaps you run as a councillor and endear us with your bottomless pit of knowledge?
niall clark
Report this comment

PS - John, looking on Wiki for your facts does not qualify you as an expert on University statistics, for all its worth you may as well be picking a picking up a copy of the Daily Star. But having read your comments I suspect you already do.
niall clark
Report this comment

The Press and Journal is happy to encourage discussion and debate on the topics featured within our newspaper and on our website.

However, we would urge people to respect the opinions of others even if they do not agree with them. We will not tolerate abusive comments of any type and such posts will be removed with the people responsible facing a ban from this website.

Only registered users can supply comments, and your registered name and location will automatically be appended to any comment that you upload.

We reserve the right to remove comments from anyone using a false name or pseudonym.

To post a comment, please login using the form at the top of the page, or click to register.